Preston Commons - Westerville Ohio Homes for Sale

This bright,open floor plan features soaring ceilings and plenty of natural light, creating a space that feels comfortable and inviting from the moment you enter the spacious living room. The great room has a fireplace and opens to the kitchen which leads out to the deck and rear yard. Upstairs, the loft offers flexible space for a home office,or cozy sitting area, while the basement gives you plenty of room for storage or future finished spaces. Located just minutes from shopping restuarants,parks and major highways,this move-in-ready home combines comfort and convenience. Come see why you'll love calling this one home!

5882 Nash Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Jennifer A Iler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: BHHS Platinum Realty Group.

$475,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226025725 MLS

Columbus Taxes + Award-Winning New Albany Schools! Beautifully updated, move-in-ready home in desirable Preston Commons featuring an open floor plan, updated flooring, recessed lighting, refreshed kitchen, and convenient first-floor laundry. The spacious owner's suite offers a renovated spa-like bath with soaking tub, walk-in shower, and walk-in closet. The finished lower level is perfect for entertaining with a custom bar, wine refrigerator, and home theater projector. Relax on the private deck surrounded by mature evergreens or enjoy cozy evenings by the gas log fireplace. Includes a whole-house water purification system plus washer and dryer. Minutes from Easton, parks, shopping, dining, John Glenn International Airport, SR-161, I-270, and downtown Columbus. A rare opportunity to enjoy top-rated New Albany Schools with the savings of Columbus taxes.

5922 Nash Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Ajay B Pandya ---- e-Merge Real Estate Unlimited

Selling Office: Red 1 Realty.

$575,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 226023502 MLS

Welcome to Preston Commons, where you'll enjoy the perfect combination of a Westerville address, Columbus taxes, and highly desirable New Albany Schools. Situated on a quiet cul de sac, this spacious 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home offers an open floor plan filled with natural light and plenty of room for everyone to spread out and enjoy. Designed with both comfort and functionality in mind, this distinctive 5 level split creates an open, airy feel while still offering privacy and separation between living spaces. The dramatic two story foyer and soaring ceilings make a lasting impression from the moment you enter. The spacious kitchen has been refreshed and serves as the heart of the home, while multiple living areas provide flexibility for entertaining, working from home, hobbies, or simply relaxing. The private primary suite occupies its own level, creating a true retreat complete with vaulted ceilings, a generous walk in closet, dual vanities, and a soaking tub. The lower level family room with a full bath offers even more living space and endless possibilities for guests, recreation, or a teen suite. For nearly 20 years, this home has been the backdrop for family gatherings, holiday celebrations, and countless everyday memories. Thoughtfully maintained and updated over the years, it is ready for its next chapter. Recent updates include a new furnace in 2025 with a transferable warranty, a refreshed kitchen, updated guest bath, recently serviced A/C system, and an updated garage storage system designed to maximize organization. Beyond the home itself, you'll love the friendly neighborhood atmosphere and convenient location just minutes from Easton, Polaris, parks, walking trails, dining, shopping, and major commuter routes.

5387 Latrobe Street, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Jeff Ramm ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Cam Taylor Co. Ltd., Realtors.

$542,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 226019162 MLS

Welcome to the Preston Commons neighborhood, where you'll enjoy the rare combination of a Westerville address, Columbus taxes, and highly desirable New Albany Schools. Thoughtfully updated and move-in ready, this inviting home offers comfortable everyday living, flexible entertaining spaces, and room for everyone to spread out and enjoy. ** The main level features new LVP flooring, fresh interior paint, a private office with French doors, built-in shelving, and a window seat, as well as formal living and dining spaces that create a warm and welcoming first impression. The spacious kitchen offers a center island, pantry, dedicated desk workspace, and updated KitchenAid and Samsung stainless steel appliances. Just beyond, the vaulted family room serves as the heart of the home with abundant natural light, a gas fireplace, and custom built-in shelving. ** Upstairs, the primary suite features vaulted ceilings, a walk-in closet, and a beautifully renovated en-suite bath with a double vanity and an oversized shower. The oversized second bedroom with a walk-in closet may quickly become the most sought-after bedroom in the house. ** The finished lower level expands the living space with a large recreation room, a kitchenette with a sink and refrigerator, a half bath, a flex area ideal for a home gym, hobby space, or playroom, and abundant storage. ** Recent improvements include a renovated primary bath, new main-level flooring, fresh interior paint, all new kitchen appliances, two new water heaters, replacement window screens, a new front screen door, professionally cleaned air ducts, and a new AC motor in 2025. ** Outside, enjoy the paver patio and spacious backyard, which provide the perfect setting for relaxing, entertaining, or spending time outdoors. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, and everyday conveniences, this exceptional home offers the perfect blend of comfort, updates, and location.

5428 Latrobe Street, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Sean M Carpenter ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Cutler Real Estate.

$440,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225040779 MLS

Welcome to this beautiful open-concept home located in the highly sought-after New Albany-Plain Local School District! This 1st-floor owner's suite home offers an ideal layout for both everyday living and entertaining. Step inside to a warm and welcoming kitchen featuring rich cherry cabinetry, a cozy eat-in area, and a convenient built-in desk—perfect for working or planning meals. The spacious living area is filled with natural light from 23 windows overlooking a serene wooded area that will never be developed and features a classic wood-burning fireplace, creating the perfect setting for relaxing evenings at home. The owner's suite includes a luxurious en-suite bath with a jacuzzi tub. Upstairs, you'll find a versatile loft area with a large walk-in closet, offering ample storage or hobby space, plus two bedrooms connected by a Jack-and-Jill bath for added comfort and functionality. The finished lower level is a true standout, featuring a full bar, full bathroom, closet, and plush carpeting—ideal for a guest suite, 4th bedroom, rec room, or second living area. The unfinished section provides abundant storage plus full hook-ups for an additional washer and dryer. Outdoor living is a dream with a wooden deck (2016) overlooking the private, tree-lined backyard. Additional updates include a new roof (2014), HVAC (2017), and garage storage system with racks, shelving, and hanging hooks (2021). Located in a kid-friendly neighborhood with an active HOA and community green space, this home offers both comfort and convenience—just minutes from SR-161, I-270, and 10 minutes to Easton. With its thoughtful design and charming details, this home is ready for you to make it your own!

5406 Bullfinch Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Ronald D Kendle ---- RE/MAX Town Center

Selling Office: RE/MAX Achievers.

$540,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225029751 MLS

Welcome to your peaceful retreat in a quiet cul-de-sac within the top-rated New Albany School District. This light-filled home features soaring 20-foot vaulted ceilings, oversized windows, and a spacious, open layout that invites relaxation and effortless entertaining. Step into modern luxury with new LVP flooring throughout the first floor (2025), a fully renovated half bath (2025), and all-new brass fixtures that add warmth and elegance. Matte black hinges and door hardware bring a stylish, cohesive finish, while the updated front door (2025), freshly painted deck (2025), and new roof (2024) provide stunning curb appeal and long-term peace of mind. The kitchen boasts Merillat cabinetry, Black Pearl granite countertops, LG stainless appliances, a prep island, and a spacious pantry. The first-floor primary suite offers cathedral ceilings and a spa-like Whirlpool jet tub. A large loft and 1,000+ sq ft basement provide space to grow. Minutes to Hamilton Quarter, Route 161, and Warner Road Park, this home blends comfort, location, and timeless charm.

5882 Nash Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Zachary R Amos ---- Revolution Realty LLC

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$400,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225027451 MLS

Welcome to this gorgeous 3-bedroom home located in the desirable Preston Commons neighborhood! New Albany school district. This home has a great floor plan with a first-floor owner's suite! Updated bathroom with large stand-up shower and jacuzzi tub, large walk-in closet. First floor laundry located near owner's suite. Two story great room with fireplace! Formal dining room, large kitchen with eat in space. Upstairs features a loft, and two additional, spacious bedrooms! One with a large walk-in closet! Full basement- great space to finish for even more living space. Great deck outback, beautifully landscaped property on a corner lot. This home is move in ready! Schedule your private tour today and fall in love with your new home.

5407 Bullfinch Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Andrena A Boyd ---- CRT, Realtors

Selling Office: Revolution Realty LLC.

$529,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 225026465 MLS

Welcome to 5494 Bullfinch Dr—a beautifully updated, thoughtfully designed home just waiting for its new owner. Located in the award-winning New Albany School District, with the added benefit of Columbus taxes and utilities, this move-in ready home checks every box for today's modern household. Step through the rich, provincial-stained craftsman-style front door and feel instantly at home. Inside, French oak hardwood floors flow across the main level, complemented by neutral, earthy tones that reflect natural light and create a calm, inviting atmosphere. At the heart of the home, the fully renovated kitchen features brand-new cabinetry, a timeless backsplash, quartz countertops and a custom island. The main floor was designed with both flexibility and accessibility in mind, offering laundry hookups in two convenient locations, a roll-in shower, and a front-entry ramp—ensuring comfort for all family members and guests, now and into the future. A brand-new HVAC system, installed in July 2025, delivers year-round comfort and peace of mind. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms with stylish herringbone-patterned carpeting and two full bathrooms. The finished basement adds even more space, complete with a fourth full bathroom and flexible areas ready to become your home theater, gym, office, or playroom—customized to suit your lifestyle. Step outside into your private backyard oasis, which includes a deck and paver patio and backs to a federally protected nature preserve—offering rare privacy, peaceful views, and a daily connection to nature. Lovingly maintained and full of thoughtful updates, 5494 Bullfinch Dr is the one you've been waiting for. Schedule your private showing today!

5494 Bullfinch Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Heather Tuvell ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

$475,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225018908 MLS

Beautiful newly updated two story home, located in Preston Commons with New Albany schools and Columbus taxes. All new kitchen appliances, backsplash and new flooring and paint throughout. Newly painted deck with stunning private setting. First floor primary suite and laundry, with an additional 3 bedrooms upstairs. Additional updates include new furnace, washer & dryer, new light fixtures, new driveway and invisible fence. OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY, JUNE 1 3:15 - 5:00

5906 Nash Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Megan E Young ---- Wagenbrenner Prof. Real Estate

Selling Office: Rock House Realty LLC.

$421,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225011405 MLS

Welcome to your next chapter in the highly sought-after Preston Commons neighborhood, located within the award-winning New Albany school district! This charming, one-owner home offers 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and a spacious, versatile layout that's ready for your personal touch. The inviting owner's suite features vaulted ceilings and a generous en suite bath—your own private retreat at the end of the day. The main level is designed for both comfortable living and easy entertaining, with a spacious kitchen that flows seamlessly into the cozy family room anchored by a gas fireplace. A formal dining room and living room provide additional flexibility for hosting or relaxing. Step outside to a peaceful backyard oasis, complete with mature trees, a deck, and a pergola—perfect for morning coffee, summer cookouts, or quiet evenings. The garden beds are ready for your green thumb, and the expansive yard offers plenty of room to play or gather. Additional highlights include a two-car attached garage for everyday convenience and a full basement offering endless possibilities—home gym, recreation room, or abundant storage. Washer and dryer included. Move right into this Preston Commons gem—don't miss your opportunity to make it yours!

5516 Latrobe Street, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Brian D Kemp ---- Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs

Selling Office: Revolution Realty LLC.

$520,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 225002195 MLS

BEAUTIFUL HOME IN HIGHLY DESIRED PRESTON COMMONS NEIGHBORHOOD! Nestled in the highly rated New Albany School District, this stunning home offers everything you've been searching for! The open floor plan features an oversized FR w/cozy gas fireplace, seamlessly flowing into the updated eat-in kitchen. You'll love the modern touches, incl granite countertops, white cabinets, LVT flooring, & newer SS refrigerator, stove, & microwave. A large pantry ensures ample storage. Spacious 3-season room and adjacent deck are perfect for relaxing or entertaining while enjoying the serene, tree-lined backyard. Large owner's suite boasts a vaulted ceiling, an ensuite bath w/ garden tub, shower, dual sinks, and a walk-in closet. Conveniently close to schools, shopping, and dining!

5866 Nash Avenue, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig Buehler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 Capital Gold.

$510,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 223031311 MLS

4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home in New Albany schools (Columbus taxes) includes a finished basement! The foyer opens to the formal dining room with wainscoting and crown molding! 1st floor showcases hardwood floors throughout! The eat-in kitchen features white cabinets w/ center island, SS appliances (gas range), granite countertops, tile backsplash, pantry & updated lighting. The great room showcases a gas fireplace with built-in bookshelves. Large owner's suite includes an ensuite bath (double vanity, soaking tub & walk-in shower) and walk-in closet with storage system. The finished basement has a separate office space and full bath rough-in! Large backyard with stamped concrete patio and fire pit is perfect for outdoor entertaining! 1st Floor Laundry.

5451 Haussman Place, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Kristin M Bell ---- ValEquity Real Estate

Selling Office: Red 1 Realty.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Preston Commons - Westerville, OH Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Preston Commons Westerville Ohio? Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Preston Commons Westerville, OH home for sale or to sell your Preston Commons Westerville Ohio home! As Realtors specializing in the Preston Commons Westerville area, we can take care of all of your Preston Commons Westerville OH real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in Preston Commons Westerville Ohio. We can also help you find distressed properties in Preston Commons Westerville including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in Preston Commons Westerville, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the Preston Commons Westerville Ohio area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the Preston Commons Westerville area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in Preston Commons Westerville Ohio, then be sure to Call or Text (614) 683-5116 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the Preston Commons Westerville, OH area! Displayed are homes for sale in Preston Commons Westerville, OH, a Subdivision located in Westerville Ohio. These Preston Commons Westerville Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Westerville MLS.