Search Westerville Homes for Sale

Olde Mill - Westerville Ohio Homes for Sale

$550,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 226025732 MLS
Welcome home to this beautifully updated and meticulously maintained 4-bedroom home in the sought-after Olde Mill neighborhood, served by award-winning Westerville Schools. Designed for the way families live today, this move-in-ready home offers spacious gathering areas, thoughtful updates, and a large fenced backyard perfect for kids, pets, and outdoor entertaining. Fresh paint and brand-new carpeting complement hardwood floors that flow through the foyer, office, dining room, kitchen, and eating area. A private first-floor office provides the ideal work-from-home space, while the formal dining room is ready for holiday dinners and family celebrations. The updated kitchen features abundant white cabinetry, granite countertops, tile backsplash, pantry, newer stainless steel appliances, and a casual dining area with new sliding doors to the patio. Open to the kitchen, the expansive family room is the heart of the home with custom wainscoting, a gas fireplace, wet bar, and plenty of space for movie nights, game days, and everyday living. Upstairs, the vaulted owner's suite offers a peaceful retreat with a walk-in closet and beautifully updated bath featuring marble look floors, double vanity, and custom glass wrapped shower. Three additional bedrooms, all with brand-new carpeting and generous closet space, provide room for a growing family, guests, or hobbies. The finished lower level adds approximately 550 square feet of flexible living space with a convenient half bath. Perfect for a playroom, teen retreat, fitness area, or media room. Outside, the landscaped quarter-acre lot offers plenty of room to play, relax, garden, or host summer cookouts. Combining timeless updates, generous living space, and an outstanding location close to parks, shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences, this is a home where you will create memories for years to come.

590 Kingfisher Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : James D Meyer ---- Cutler Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Achievers.

$485,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 226021423 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully well maintained 4-bedroom home in the highly desirable Olde Mill subdivision. Freshly painted and featuring brand new carpeting. This move in ready residence offers an exceptional blend of comfort, style, and functionality. The finished basement adds approximately 540 square feet of flexible living space and includes a full bathroom, ideal for a home office, media room, recreation area, fitness studio, or guest retreat also with a full a bathroom. Outside find your own private backyard oasis, where a spacious paver patio with a built-in fire pit creates the perfect setting for entertaining friends, hosting family gatherings, or enjoying quiet evenings under the stars. The wooded, fenced backyard provides both privacy and tranquility. Inside, you'll find thoughtful upgrades and distinctive features throughout, including imported Italian tile flooring in the entryway, fireplaces in both the family room and primary suite, a generous formal dining room, and an oversized living room. The custom designed 3-season room offers additional living space to enjoy throughout much of the year, while the charming bay window in the kitchen dining area fills the home with natural light. This is a rare opportunity to own a truly special home in one of the area's most sought after neighborhoods. Schedule your showing today and experience all that this exceptional property has to offer.

715 Sugar Court, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Oheneba K Amponsah ---- Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs

Selling Office: Cutler Real Estate.

$580,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 226017916 MLS
Tucked away on one of the largest lots in sought-after Olde Mill, this exceptional 2 story home sits on a private, wooded, fenced lot of over 1/3 acre offering space, charm, and an unbeatable Westerville location. A welcoming full front porch sets the tone as you step into the spacious foyer. Just off the entry, you'll find a private first-floor den and an impressive great room featuring hardwood floors and a stunning brick hearth woodburning fireplace. The beautifully remodeled kitchen and dining area are designed for gathering and entertaining with an oversized island, gas cooktop, stainless steel appliances, black walnut cabinetry, and granite countertops. Upstairs, discover 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths, including a Jack-and-Jill bath with hall access and a luxurious newly remodeled primary bath complete with heated ceramic tile floors, dual granite vanities, a walk-in shower, and corner whirlpool tub. The finished lower level offers incredible versatility boasting a rec room, fitness area, game room, and more, highlighted by a bar area, woodburning stove, and convenient half bath. Outside, the expansive backyard retreat features a brick paver patio and outdoor kitchen space with a bar, gas grill, & refrigerator, perfect for entertaining or relaxing in the peaceful wooded setting. A rare 4-car garage--2 deep and 2 wide--with heating and cooling is a true standout feature showcasing RaceDeck garage flooring! Additional updates include a newer roof (2020), Rosati windows throughout (2024), a new hot water tank (2026), & new sump pump (2026). Ideally located near schools, parks, the Westerville Bike Path, shopping, dining, and more, this is a rare opportunity in one of Westerville's most desirable neighborhoods.

605 Kingfisher Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Monica L Cook ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Alt Company, Realtors.

$530,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 225028658 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully updated 4-5 bedroom, 3.5 bath home in the highly sought-after Olde Mill community! Just a short walk to schools and minutes from Uptown Westerville, Polaris, restaurants, and Hoover Reservoir, this spacious home blends charm, function, and style. The showstopper kitchen features marble countertops, imported handmade zellige backsplash, designer appliances, new flooring, canned lighting, a custom wood beam, and floating shelves. The adjacent dining room includes built-in storage, a board and batten wall treatment, and a stylish new light fixture.Main living spaces have been refreshed with updated trim, doors, windows, and fresh paint throughout. The family room includes a gas fireplace, custom built-ins, and a wood beam mantle. A formal living room (or playroom) adds flexibility with additional built-ins. The main floor also offers a home office or den and first-floor laundry. Upstairs, you'll find generously sized bedrooms with charming details like shiplap and wainscoting feature walls. The spacious owner's suite boasts cathedral ceilings, a jetted tub, and updated paint throughout. The refreshed half bath includes a modern mirror and updated fixtures.The finished lower level offers even more space with a large rec room, a full bath, and a 5th bedroom or flex room—ideal for guests, a teen suite, or a home gym. Outside, enjoy a peaceful backyard view from the deck, bordered by mature pines. The fully fenced backyard also includes a storage shed, a few raised garden beds, and room to relax, play or entertain. The front entry features new windows, a painted stair railing and front door, and a stylish light fixture. The Roof was installed in 2018 and the HVAC in 2023! This thoughtfully updated, move-in-ready home offers comfort, character, and a fantastic location near shopping, dining, and parks!

568 Kingfisher Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig Buehler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$450,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 225023641 MLS
Welcome to this stunning gem in the highly sought-after Olde Mill community of Westerville! This beautifully maintained and freshly painted home is move-in ready and perfectly situated on a quiet cul-de-sac lot—ideal for families seeking comfort, space, and convenience. Step inside to discover a bright main level featuring expansive living and dining rooms—perfect for entertaining or family gatherings. The sunlit kitchen flows seamlessly into a spacious family room complete with a cozy fireplace and built-in bookshelves. The first floor office with closet faces the front yard and could easily serve as a fifth bedroom. Newly refinished hardwood floors run from the entryway through the kitchen and family room, while brand new carpet enhances the rest of the home. Upstairs, you'll find an oversized primary suite with a newly remodeled en-suite bath, along with three additional bedrooms, a large hall closet, and a newly remodeled full hall bath. The lower level offers even more flexible space, large glass block windows, a wet bar with refrigerator and ample storage—ideal for guests, a home gym, or a recreation area. Step outside to your well-lit private backyard oasis, with beautiful updated paver patio—perfect for relaxing or entertaining under the stars. Conveniently located near K-12 schools, parks, bike paths, Uptown Westerville, Hoover Reservoir, shopping, dining, and more. This home is a true 10+—don't miss your chance to make it yours!

750 Pepper Court, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Sandy L Raines ---- The Raines Group, Inc.

Selling Office: Baker Realty Group.

$555,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 225018712 MLS
WELCOME TO YOUR DREAM HOME IN THE HIGHLY SOUGHT-AFTER OLDE MILL COMMUNITY! This stunning custom-built 5 bedroom, 3.5-bath home is loaded with upgrades, timeless charm, and thoughtful design throughout, perfectly situated on an oversized 1/3-acre lot offering space, privacy, and beautiful mature landscaping. Step inside and you'll be welcomed by a spacious layout that includes a large entryway, formal dining room w/ tray ceiling, private den w/ built-in bookshelves, & spacious great room w/ vaulted ceilings, skylights, wainscoting & cozy gas log fireplace w/ white brick hearth. The chef's kitchen boasts SS appliances, granite counters, gas range & bayed breakfast nook filled w/ natural light. A formal living room adds extra space for entertaining or relaxing. Hardwood floors flow through much of the main level, adding warmth & elegance. Upstairs features a luxurious owner's suite w/ soaring ceilings, spa-like bath w/ dual vanities, soaking/Jacuzzi tub, separate shower, & massive walk-in closet w/ dormer window. 3 additional generously sized bedrooms provide plenty of space for everyone. The professionally finished lower level w/ 1,200 SF is a game-changer including a potential 5th BR, full bath, kitchenette, cozy living area w/ gas fireplace & abundant storage—perfect for guests, in-laws, or private retreat. Tons of storage throughout incl 2 entry closets, large upstairs hallway closet, generous LL storage space and cabinets/shelving in the garage. Outside, enjoy peaceful outdoor living with a covered deck, built-in firepit, and picturesque yard framed by mature trees. The side-load garage enhances the curb appeal, Prime location within walking distance to Westerville schools & parks. Minutes to Hoover Reservoir, Uptown Westerville, Polaris, Easton, dining, shopping & freeway access. This home checks every box for location, luxury & space!

538 Olde Mill Drive, Westerville

Listing Courtesy of : Craig Buehler ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Olde Mill - Westerville, OH Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Olde Mill Westerville Ohio? Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Olde Mill Westerville, OH home for sale or to sell your Olde Mill Westerville Ohio home! As Realtors specializing in the Olde Mill Westerville area, we can take care of all of your Olde Mill Westerville OH real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in Olde Mill Westerville Ohio. We can also help you find distressed properties in Olde Mill Westerville including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in Olde Mill Westerville, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the Olde Mill Westerville Ohio area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the Olde Mill Westerville area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in Olde Mill Westerville Ohio, then be sure to Call or Text (614) 683-5116 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the Olde Mill Westerville, OH area! Displayed are homes for sale in Olde Mill Westerville, OH, a Subdivision located in Westerville Ohio. These Olde Mill Westerville Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Westerville MLS.