Kelleys Island Ohio Homes for Sale

$1,058,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 226037213 MLS

1036 W Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of : NON MEMBER ---- NON MEMBER OFFICE

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$479,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5243717 MLS

Completely Remodeled - Turn-Key ~ 2 Bedroom/ 2 Bath Lower Level Unit Overlooking the Quarry Pond. Early Morning Coffee In the Sun, Afternoons In the Shade On the Back Deck! Currently Used As A Vacation Home and Income Producing Rental. Common Areas Include: The Pool, Charcoal BBQ / Picnic Area, Basketball Court and Kids Fishing Area. Additional Private Storage Space Included.

111 W Lakeshore Unit 4B, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$579,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5241234 MLS

Move-In Ready 4 BR / 2.5 BA Home in Central Kelleys Island! This Home is Situated in the Highly Desirable, Family-Friendly Sweet Valley Estates Subdivision. Centrally Located on Kelleys Island, this Property Puts you Just a Short Golf-Cart Ride from Local Beaches, State Parks, Restaurants, and Marinas while offering a Peaceful Neighborhood Atmosphere. With Four Spacious Bedrooms and 2.5 Baths, this Layout is Perfectly Suited for Family Living or Hosting Guests. The Home is Immaculately Maintained and Completely Ready for its New Owners. HVAC was UPDATED in 2018. Over 750 Sq Ft of Decking and Patio Allow for Taking Your Daily Life Outside! Store Your Island Toys and Tool in the 16 x 12 Shed and Carport. Furniture is Negotiable, Potentially Making Your Transition onto The Island Completely Seamless. Don't miss this Rare Opportunity for Island Living - Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

404 Sweetvalley, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$160,000

5234447 MLS

Discover the perfect place to Build your island dream! This unique offering includes four adjoining wooded parcels being sold together as one expansive property on desirable Beach Road on beautiful Kelleys Island. Surrounded by mature trees and backing up to the island's historic quarry’ this property offers privacy, tranquility, and a beautiful natural setting. Whether you're planning a year-round residence or a vacation retreat, you'll enjoy the peaceful surroundings while being just minutes from beaches, marinas, restaurants, wineries, parks, and all the charm Kelleys Island has to offer. Opportunities to own a wooded property of this size in such a desirable location are rare. Don't miss your chance to own your own piece of island paradise!

Beach Road, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Teresa Maher, realtorteresamaher@gmail.com With Red 1 Realty, LLC

$749,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5229331 MLS

Rare opportunity to bring your vision to life on Kelleys Island! Situated on 3.37 wooded acres, this property offers exceptional space, privacy, and flexibility to create your own island retreat. Whether you're looking to enjoy the property as it is, expand, or customize to suit your own vision, the acreage provides endless potential in a peaceful natural setting. Conveniently located near the Kelleys Island Land Field Airport, the property offers easy year-round accessibility while maintaining a private feel. Originally built in 1978 and remodeled in 2002, the three-bedroom home features an open-concept kitchen and living area designed for gathering and entertaining. Front and rear decks extend the living space outdoors, offering inviting places to relax and enjoy the beauty and comfort of island life. A spacious pole barn provides excellent storage space. This is your chance to own a special piece of Kelleys Island while enjoying the flexibility that a property of this size provides. Schedule your private showing today! Buyers should do their own due diligence. Measurements are approximate. Agent is relative of Seller.

522 Monaghan Road, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Kelsey Haig, Kelsey.haig@gmail.com With Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Professional Realty

$1,058,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5220771 MLS

Experience Island Living at its Finest in this 2,100 sq. ft. Waterfront Ranch, Perfectly Positioned on 1+ Acres Along Kelleys Island's Coveted West-End. With Nearly 300 Feet of Private Lake Frontage, this Exceptional Property Showcases Sweeping Panoramic Views and Unforgettable Lake Erie Sunsets! Take Advantage of this Properties Shoreline and Build your own Private Dock and Outdoor Living Space along the Waterfront! This Inviting Home Features 4 Bedrooms and 2 Full Baths, offering Plenty of Room for Family and Guests. A new Furnace Installed in 2022 Adds Comfort and Peace of Mind, while the Spacious Screened Composite Front Porch provides the Perfect setting to Relax and take in the Tranquil Surroundings. Whether you are Looking for a Serene Personal Retreat, a Legacy Island Getaway, or a Smart Waterfront Investment, this Property Delivers a Rare Blend of Location, Space, and Flexibility. Just Minutes from all the Charm and Amenities Kelleys Island has to Offer, this is a special Opportunity to Own a True Lake Erie Treasure! Call Today to Schedule Your Private Showing!

1036 W Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$300,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5212772 MLS

Tucked-Away Island Retreat Located in the Quiet, Less-traveled Section of the Family-Friendly Sunset Point Subdivision. This 2-bed, 1-bath Bungalow offers 720 sq. ft. of Comfortable Living Space. The 400-sq. ft. Garage is Perfect for Storing Bikes, Tools, or your Lake Lifestyle Gear. Both the home and garage feature durable Metal Roofs for low-maintenance ownership.Off the back of the house you will find a Serene and Tranquil area Featuring a 250 sq. ft. Wooden Deck and Pergola. Inside, you'll find a functional layout with mid-range finishes, offering a clean slate for a buyer ready to add personal touches and value over time. Whether you're envisioning simple cosmetic updates or a more customized refresh, this property provides a great opportunity to make it your own. Currently used as a Short-Term rental with a Loyal Base of Longtime Repeat Guests currently booked through Thanksgiving. Continue renting As-Is, or Convert it into your Own Private Island Getaway! Call Today for Your Private Showing.

136 Sunset Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$749,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5204668 MLS

The Wigwam, a beautifully restored and fully renovated 1860 cottage on Kelleys Island, set on roughly .75 acres with space to relax and entertain. This 4-bedroom home blends historic character with thoughtful updates, offering flexibility as your own island home, a rental, or a mix of both, and with the separate guest studio, it lives like a 5-bedroom. Inside, you'll find an open-concept layout with a fully updated kitchen, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, farmhouse sink, and a dedicated coffee bar. The dining area is designed for gathering, and the home has been professionally styled to blend historic character with fresh, modern finishes throughout. Outdoor space includes a spacious yard, patio, fire pit, and multiple areas for relaxing and entertaining. Currently operating as a successful short-term rental with an established history, this property offers flexibility as a personal island home, income-producing property, or a combination of both. Furnishings are negotiable for a potential turnkey transition.

321 Harbor Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Steve Mack, stevemack.ki@gmail.com With Century 21 Bolte Real Estate

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$105,000

5205455 MLS

Tucked away deep within the peaceful Sweetbriar subdivision, this corner, oversized 0.437-acre lot offers the perfect canvas for your Kelleys Island dream home. Located on a lightly traveled street where the only traffic is the occasional golf cart, this 141' x 135' corner property provides the privacy and space a growing family needs. Adventure is just steps away with Lake Erie access at the end of both Melody and Cedar Lanes perfect for launching kayaks or enjoying the sunset over the water. With city water available at the street and a prime location away from the downtown bustle, this is a rare opportunity to secure a substantial footprint in one of the island's most serene neighborhoods

100-102 Orchard Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$159,999

5204511 MLS

Desirable Oversized Residential Lot (0.809 Acres) With Lake Erie Access at the End of the Street. Street to Street Access on West and Eastern Fronts (100' frontage on Melody, 150' Frontage on Memory Lane). Site and Soil Review Suggests Property Will Support a House, Pole Barn and 3-4 Bedroom Septic Waste Water Treatment System. City Water is Available on Melody Lane. Call Today For Your Private Showing!

220 Melody, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$125,000

5200759 MLS

Discover the perfect spot to build your family retreat on this spacious 4-parcel lot totaling 0.77 acres (200' x 168'). Tucked away in a peaceful part of family-friendly Kelleys Island, this property is just steps from the Boardwalk Trail leading to the Kelleys Island Nature Preserve and Sandy Beach, and close to Horseshoe Lake's hiking and biking trails. With site and soil tests already completed, you can start planning your island dream home right away. There's plenty of room here for outdoor living, backyard games, or space to park the golf cart for island adventures. Whether you envision a cozy cottage or a gathering place for family and friends, this oversized lot offers endless possibilities and a setting that's sure to bring a lifetime of beach days, bonfires, and lasting memories! Call today for Your Private Showing!

15 Hamilton, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$275,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5195629 MLS

Welcome to 211 Orchard on peaceful Kelleys Island, a Newly Renovated Island Retreat offering 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, and over 670 sq ft of comfortable living space. This Bright, Inviting Home features all new appliances and fresh finishes throughout, so you can move right in and start enjoying island life. Step Outside through the Slider onto a Large Wooden Deck, then down to a great poured-concrete fire pit area - perfect for storytelling under the stars and gathering with friends and family on warm summer nights. Lake Erie is just down the street, with water access at the end of both Cedar and Melody Lanes, making it easy to swim, paddle, or simply take in the views. Kelleys Island is known for its family-oriented, laid-back atmosphere, and this property puts you right in the heart of that relaxed, welcoming community.

211 Orchard Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$631,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5195062 MLS

A Peaceful Kelleys Island Retreat - Private Compound on 1.65 Acres! Tucked away on a quiet dead-end street just moments from downtown, this beautifully cared-for year-round home offers the best of island living, privacy, space, and comfort. Spread across five parcels totaling over 1.65 acres, this rare find includes a charming home, spacious barn, and large attached garage, all lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated. Recent upgrades bring peace of mind: a 30-year roof (2025), high-efficiency furnace (2016), and brand-new Trane central air system (2025). Inside, nearly every room has been refreshed to blend modern convenience with cozy island warmth. Step into the sunroom (17x12, added 2006) or relax on one of three inviting decks. A front porch (15x8, added 2009) welcomes guests with classic island charm. Outbuildings include a 30x28 barn with a screened-in room, perfect for hobbies or entertaining, plus a 24x24 attached garage offering plenty of storage for golf carts, kayaks, and bikes. A fenced-in garden (30x28) provides your own slice of farm-to-table living, supported by a 2,000-gallon septic system designed for year-round comfort. Set within easy walking distance to the Huntley/Beatty Quarry scenic trails of the Kelleys Island Park District, this property is ideal for families, nature lovers, or anyone seeking a serene getaway with every convenience close by. Don't miss this secluded island compound, schedule your private showing today and experience Kelleys Island living at its best!

110 Pickerel, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$945,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5192073 MLS

Rare opportunity to own true Lake Erie frontage with no road between you and the water. Located on a private drive in the desirable East Point Subdivision on Kelleys Island, this beautifully remodeled home offers privacy, breathtaking views, and effortless Island Life and Living! Completely rebuilt and expanded with a large open addition in 2024, the home features extensive updates including a new roof, siding, stone exterior, windows, HVAC, framing, subfloor and joists, kitchen, bathrooms, appliances, electrical, plumbing, and spray foam insulation. Every detail was thoughtfully upgraded for modern comfort and long-term durability. Inside, the spacious layout includes 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, comfortably accommodating up to 12 guests. Large windows throughout the home capture stunning Lake Erie views from nearly every room, filling the interior with natural light and waterfront scenery. The custom kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring custom cabinetry and granite countertops, with the same quality finishes carried through all bathrooms. New Paved Road to Be Installed in 2026. Seller Will Cover the Cost of Road. Outdoor living is just as impressive. Relax on the spacious front porch overlooking the water, or entertain guests on the large stamped concrete back patio perfect for gatherings after a day on the lake. Just steps away, your private Lake Erie frontage provides a front-row seat to island sunsets and waterfront recreation. Furnishings are negotiable. Enjoy everything Kelleys Island has to offer, including charming shops, popular restaurants, scenic walking trails, and a beautiful state park, all just minutes away. Schedule Your Private Showing Today.

104 E Point Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$382,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5186725 MLS

Charming Ranch on Kelleys Island Enjoy Easy, Single-Floor Living in this Inviting 2-Bedroom, 1-Bath Ranch Located in a Private, Family-Friendly Neighborhood. Perfectly Situated between Downtown Kelleys Island and Kelleys Island State Park and Sandy Beach, this Home offers Both Convenience and Tranquility. The Open Floor Plan Creates a Bright and Welcoming Living Space, ideal for Relaxing or Entertaining. The Kitchen Flows Seamlessly into the Living Area, and the Full Bath features a Tub and Shower Combo for Comfort and Functionality. Step outside to a Covered Front Porch Perfect for Morning Coffee and a Spacious Wooden Sun Deck off the Back, Ready for Summer Gatherings. The Attached 2+ Car Garage Provides Plenty of Room for Vehicles, Boats, Golf Carts, Bikes and Extra Storage, Complemented by an Oversized Pantry/Storage Room. New Roof in 2019! City Water. Paved Road. Septic System Features Multiple Leachfields Whether You're Looking for a Year-Round Residence or a Seasonal Getaway, This Well-Located Ranch Offers the Perfect Island Retreat.

410 Sweet Valley Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$189,000

5173592 MLS

Location, Location, Location! Three Parcel ~ 1.13 Acre Residential Lot Located In Desirable Vineyard Estates Subdivision! City Water Available At the Street. Site and Soil Performed!

Chardonnay, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

$409,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5150806 MLS

Great Island Starter! - This 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Ranch is Located on The Island's Southeast Side. Fairview Lane is a Quiet and Less Traveled Road, Versus those of Nearby Streets and Neighborhoods. En Suite Master! The 24 x 12 Shed was added in 2018 (Perfect to Hide Your Island Rides and Toys). This Property is Currently used as a Family Vacation Home and Short Term Rental. Call Today to Schedule Your Private Showing.

121 Fairview Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$82,750

5143642 MLS

141 x 116 (0.375 Acre) Lot in Desirable Vineyard Estates Subdivision. City Water is Available at the Street. Lot is Currently Subject to Septic Design and Septic Approval, Two Bedroom Septic Design Work Completed.

Chardonnay, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$85,000

5143619 MLS

0.374 Acre Buildable Lot Located on The Island's Eastern Side. Lake Erie Access At End of Harbor Lane. City Water Available at the Street. Site and Soil Tests Performed.

Harbor Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$440,000

5143612 MLS

This One Acre Lakefront Lot is located on Kelleys Island's Southern Shore. See Marblehead Lighthouse and Cedar Point from Your Front Yard. Septic Design Approved. City Water Available at The Street. Newly Constructed 36 x 24 Pole Barn on Rear of Property. Call Today for Your Private Showing!

705 E Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$665,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5143575 MLS

Wow! Stunning Lake views From Multiple Rooms and Decks Makes This a Very Unique Island Home! This 4 Bedroom, 3 Bath Home Is Located in The Desirable Southaven Subdivision. Three Of The Bedrooms Are Located on The First Floor With A Mother-In-Law Suite Located Upstairs with Private Elevated Lakeview Deck and Bathroom! Kitchen and Living Room Have Been Recently Updated! Paved Driveway Leads to The Two Car Garage Located on The Back End of The Property. Lake Erie Access Is Just Down The Street. Enjoy The Views From the Association Deck Overlooking The Lake and Beach! Seeing Is Believing! Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

103 Southaven Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Keller Williams Elevate.

$837,500

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5143543 MLS

One of a Kind, Secluded Property With Panoramic Lake Erie Views From Both Levels and Decks! The 2,268 Square Foot Open Floor Plan, and Thoughtful Design of This Custom Home Make Morning Sunrises A Priority! The Reverse Floor Plans Allows For Optimal Birds-Eye Views of The Lake. The Second Floor Features Main Kitchen, Dining and Living Areas and Master Bedroom. The Master Has an Oversized Walk-In Closet, Walk-In Super Shower and Slider to The 1450+ Sq Foot Deck. Down Stairs Is Comprised of A Super Bonus Room with Garage Door, Additional Suite with Bedroom, Bath and Kitchen, Dining, Living Room Combo. You Must View This Property To Appreciate The Design and Craftsmanship! Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

201 Morning Glory Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$960,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5119650 MLS

Lake Erie Islands waterfront paradise. Rare access to Lake Erie with no road in between. Located in East Point Subdivision on private drive. COMPLETELY REMODELED AND LARGE OPEN ADDITION IN 2021. New roof, siding, stone, windows, HVAC, framing, subfloor and joist, kitchen, baths, appliances, electrical, spray foam insulation and plumbing. 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths with the ability to SLEEP 12. Water views from every window. Custom cabinets with granite counters throughout. OUTDOOR SPACES WITH SPACIOUS FRONT PORCH AND LARGE STAMPED CONCRETE BACK PATIO WITH ROOM FOR RELAXING AND ENTERTAINING. ALL STEPS FROM YOUR OWN PRIVATE LAKEFRONT PARADISE. FURNITURE INCLUDED. Rare opportunity to own on a spectacular Island with plenty of shopping, restaurants, walking trails, and a state park.

104 E Point Road, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Lorenzo Gentile, Lorenzo@GentileRE.com With Gentile Real Estate LLC

Selling Office: Gentile Real Estate LLC.

$168,900

5114871 MLS

Private, Oversized Lot (1.07 acre - 185' x 252'), With Lake Erie Access at The End Of Woodford Lane. The Large Lot Can Support Multiple Structures While Leaving Plenty of Room for Privacy! Call Today For Your Private Showing.

10 Pheasant Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$475,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5112082 MLS

Wow! Windows With A View! This Is A Rare Opportunity To Obtain A Island Lakefront Home in The Keampfe/Johanna Sandy Beach Community on The North Bay of Kelleys Island. The Neighborhood Features Over 550' of Community Lakefront. Do Not Let This Once In A Lifetime Opportunity Slip Away! Call Today for Your Private Showing!

208 Johanna Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Century 21 Bolte Real Estate.

$180,000

5110843 MLS

Beautiful Lakeview Lot in Desirable Southaven Woods. Lot is 100 x 189 (0.4339 acres). Lot is Subject to Kelleys Island Zoning and Erie Health Department Requirements for Building and Waste Water Treatment System. Water is available at the street. Septic System Will Need to Be Installed. Lake Erie Access is just Steps away from the Property at The HOA Maintained Lakefront Deck at The Front of The Subdivision. Call Today for Your Private Showing!

V/L 1 Southaven Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$450,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5110779 MLS

Time To Become An Islander! This 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath Home Was Constructed in 2010. Unwind, Relax and Entertain on the Oversized Back Deck with Gazebo (378 Sq Ft of TREX Decking). Kitchen Features Black Granite Countertops! Store Your Island Toys in the Oversized One Car Attached Garage. Downstairs Flooring is a Mix of Hardwood and Vinyl, While Upstairs is Carpet and Vinyl. Lake Erie Access at The End of Both Cedar and Melody Lanes. Crawl Space is Poured Concrete! Furnishings Are Negotiable. Call and Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

145 Orchard Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty.

$510,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5109104 MLS

Built in 2010, This Island Oasis Getaway is Move In Ready! The 4 Bedroom, 2 Bath Home Has All The Amenities of Home and Much, Much More! Check Out The Pool and Oversized Cabana! Cabana Has Electric and Overhead Fans So You Can Enjoy Even The Hottest Summer Days Outside! Over 1000 Sq Feet of Brand New, Top-of-The-Line Trex Decking! Unpack, Relax, Recharge and Enjoy. Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

203 Lower Cliff Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$499,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5106578 MLS

Enjoy the Best of Island Living in This Charming New Construction Home! Thoughtfully Designed with a Turnkey, Open-Concept Layout, This Home Maximizes Space and Style. The Modern Kitchen Features Quartz Countertops and Stylish Finishes, While Hard Surface Flooring Flows Throughout for Easy Maintenance. The Cozy Primary Suite Includes an En Suite Bath with Beautiful Tile Work, Creating a Relaxing Retreat. A Two-Car Garage Adds Convenience and Extra Storage. It Also Offers the Exciting Potential to Be an Income-Producing Property. Beach/Lake Erie Access at the End of Both Melody and Cedar Lanes. Cistern water. Move Right in and Start Enjoying this Beautifully Designed Home and Island Life This Summer! Call and Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

116 Fernwood Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$439,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5104361 MLS

Escape, Relax and Recharge! Come to Kelleys Island and Enjoy Lake Erie and Island Life to it's Fullest! This 2 bed, 1 bath Ranch was finished in 2016. North Beach Access just 700' Away! Newly Installed MiniSplit System for Year Round Heating and Cooling. Furnishings are Negotiable.

707 Monaghan Road, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$375,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 225002110 MLS

Entered for Comps Only

422 Division Street, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of : NON MEMBER ---- NON MEMBER OFFICE

Selling Office: Rise Realty.

$78,750

5079358 MLS

Over-sized, Partially Cleared Lot in Desirable Sweetbriar Subdivision on Island's Southeast Side. The 150x141 (0.4855 acre) Lot Is Nearly ready to Break Ground! Call Today to Schedule a Private Showing.

128 Memory Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$64,000

5079339 MLS

Large Buildable Fully Wooded Lot Located in the Desirable Sweetbriar Subdivision on Kelleys Islands Southeast Side. Lot is 150x141 (0.4855 Acres).

Lots 71-73 Memory Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$80,000

5076469 MLS

Lot 2 Chardonnay Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 3E, Kelleys Island

$420,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5075025 MLS

Welcome to your waterfront slice of paradise on Kelleys Island! This charming ground-floor condo boasts stunning views of the quarry lake and fountain from the living room, dining area, and deck. With two bedrooms, two full baths, and a spacious living room featuring a wood-burning fireplace and wet bar, it's perfect for relaxation and entertaining. Enjoy the convenience of parking right at your front door, nearby heated in-ground fenced pool access, and beautifully maintained grounds. Recent upgrades include a new HVAC system, hot water tank, and laminate flooring, which were all completed in 2019. Ideally located near marinas, restaurants, shops, and ferries, this condo offers the perfect blend of tranquility and accessibility. Pets allowed per HOA rules. This is the island living experience you've been dreaming of!

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 3E, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Steve Mack, stevemack.ki@gmail.com With Century 21 Bolte Real Estate

Selling Office: Century 21 Bolte Real Estate.

$505,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5072963 MLS

Experience the charm of island living on Kelleys Island's north shore! This delightful 3-bedroom home features an original island-built fireplace in the open-concept living area, seamlessly connecting to the kitchen and dining space. Enjoy additional living space in the expansive 12 x 22-foot sunroom, perfect for relaxing and entertaining. Situated in the serene Kaempfe subdivision, this property offers private access to a community sand beach, concrete dock/pier, and a newly constructed steel and concrete seawall/shore dock completed in 2024. A 20 x 28 metal pole barn with a concrete floor and electric door opener provides ample storage for your island toys. Accessible from Elsie Shultz Lane and Kaempfe Lane, this private road location offers tranquility and convenience. Make this peaceful retreat your new island getaway!

136 Elsie Schultz Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Steve Mack, stevemack.ki@gmail.com With Century 21 Bolte Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$360,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5072658 MLS

Move In Ready Two Bed, Two Bath. House Is Currently Used As Second Home and Income Producing Vacation Home. Contents Are Negotiable! Over 400 Sq Feet of Porch and Deck. Lake Erie Access at The End of Cedar Lane. Eat In Kitchen and Full Laundry. Call Today To Schedule Your Private Showing.

212 Cedar Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$300,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5072504 MLS

Move In Ready Three Bed, Two Bath. House Is Currently Used As Second Home and Income Producing Vacation Rental. Contents Are Negotiable! Lake Erie Access at The End of Melody Lane. Eat In Kitchen and Full Laundry. Call Today To Schedule Your Private Showing.

224 Melody Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$80,500

5068131 MLS

141 x 117 (0.3787 ACRE) Lot Is Located in The Desirable Vineyard Estates Subdivision. Site and Soil Review Performed. City Water Is Available At The Street. Call Today For Your Private Showing!

15 Chardonnay Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$170,000

5058369 MLS

Oversized Buildable Lot with Lakeviews (0.6041 Acres - 100 x 300). Site and Soil Review Performed. City Water Available at the Street. To Get A Full Understanding of The Layout and Views It It Highly Suggested To Schedule A Private Showing.

V/L McGettigan Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$380,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5045021 MLS

Look at That View!!! Incredible Opportunity to Enjoy Island Life Along The Shores of Lake Erie. This Two Bedroom Cottage is Located in One of Kelleys Island's Most Desirable Private Beach Communities (Kaempfe/Johanna Subdivision). The Neighborhood Features Over 550' of Community Lakefront. Do Not Let This Once In A Lifetime Opportunity Slip Away! Call Today for Your Private Showing!

206 Johanna Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 6E, Kelleys Island

$367,500

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5037093 MLS

Stunning Views from This 2 Bed, 2 Bath Ground Floor Entry Condo Located in The Desirable Kelleys Island Quarry Condo Complex, Downtown Kelleys Island. The Unit is Currently Used as Vacation Home and Income Producing Property. Furniture is Negotiable. Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 6E, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$1,600,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 224012121 MLS

Idyllic waterfront property for those who appreciates both luxury and natural beauty. Breathtaking views that can be enjoyed from almost every corner. The residence features 6 spacious bedrooms and 5.5 baths, with accommodations set up for 16 people, it's perfect for entertaining. The wall of windows offers uninterrupted views of the serene lake. Inside, the property has been meticulously updated, including all-new flooring and modernized bathrooms. The kitchen is equipped with a new 12x5 island, ideal for cooking and socializing. The primary bedroom is truly luxurious, featuring a private office and a stunning bathroom complete with a shower/tub room. Each bedroom has its own private balcony. Situated on almost an acre of land, it's the perfect blend of island living and comfort!

204 Mc Gettigan Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of : Heather Byrne ---- KW Classic Properties Realty

Selling Office: NON MEMBER OFFICE.

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 2D, Kelleys Island

$380,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5031481 MLS

Welcome to your slice of paradise on Kelleys Island! This condo offers a second-floor retreat with breathtaking lake views from the living room, dining area, and deck. With two bedrooms and two full baths, and a spacious living room enhanced with vaulted ceilings and skylights creating an airy ambiance throughout. The view of the lake from this unit is unmatched within the condo community. Convenience meets luxury with double parking right at your doorstep, nearby pool access, and well-maintained grounds. Recent upgrades include a new HVAC system in 2023 and new skylights installed in 2021. Situated near marinas, restaurants, shops, and ferries, this condo offers the perfect blend of tranquility and accessibility. This is the island living experience you've been looking for!

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 2D, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Steve Mack, stevemack.ki@gmail.com With Century 21 Bolte Real Estate

Selling Office: North Bay Realty, LLC..

$51,900

5023679 MLS

100 X 141 Lot Located in Sweetbriar Subdivision on Island's Southeast Side. Lot is Subject to Kelleys Island Zoning and Erie County Wastewater Approval. At This Time City Water Is Not Available At The Street (Well or Cistern would be Only Options for Water Supply).

Lots 81-82 Memory Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$155,000

5022999 MLS

Oversized Buildable Lot (1.075 Acre - 185 x 253) With City Water Available At The Street. Lake Erie Access at Deeded Park at End of Woodford. Property is Subject To Kelleys Island Zoning and Erie County Waste Water Treatment Approval. Call Today to Have a Private Showing of This Great Property!

Lot 7 Pheasant Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$350,000

5022726 MLS

Five Plus Acres Residential Lot. City Water is Available. Access off Orchard and Trailer Lanes (North Side of Melody Lane). Potential Subdivision Subject To Kelleys Island Zoning and Waste Water Treatment System Approval. Call For Your Private Showing Today!

V/L E Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$165,000

5022253 MLS

V/L McGettigan Lane, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$775,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5021384 MLS

Step Back In Time At This Absolutely Stunning Historic Home (1864). The 1.568 Acre Lot Has 185' of Lake Erie Frontage. While Move In Ready for Immediate Use, This Property Offers So Many Possibilities For The Next Owner! Call Today To Schedule Your Private Showing!

723 E Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Keller Williams Chervenic Rlty.

$423,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5019470 MLS

Upstairs 3 bedroom, 3 bath Unit with Sunset View off The Back Deck. Newly replaced HVAC and Hot Water Tank. Flooring Updated in 2021! Condo Comes Turn-Key. Unit Is Currently Used As A Vacation Home and Income Producing Rental. All Tenants To Transfer. Schedule Your Private Showing Today!

111 W Lakeshore Unit 8C, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$726,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4495401 MLS

This Secluded 1,850 Sq. Ft. Ranch Rests on 1.6 Acres of Land That Backs Up to The Huntley-Beatty Preserve, and Conveniently Just Steps from The Downtown Area. The Nine Parcel Property Could Allow for Potential Future Development (Site and Soil Test Performed - Additional Parcels May Support an Additional Two or Three Bedroom Home Overlooking The Quarry). Enjoy Privacy from The 6 Person Hot Tub While Watching Sunsets Nighty from Your Back Yard (No Neighbors in Visible Site). Outdoor Cooking Station With Kamado Joe & Weber Gas Grill. Also Included is Full-House Generator! The Large Yard Features a Tree Fort & Climbing Wall & Lots of Green Space. The Home Has Been Recently Updated to Enjoy the Property Year-round. The 28' x 36' Barn Was Built in 2018. Barn Features Full Concrete Floor & 28' x 16' Loft and 12' x 14' Door. The Oversized (27' x 46) Basement Has Full Concrete Floor & Is Perfect for Storage!

101 Pickerel Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 5F, Kelleys Island

$425,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5013665 MLS

Highly Desirable, Recently Updated, End Unit Located Near Downtown Kelleys Island. Currently Used As a Second Home and Income Producing Vacation Rental. Enjoy The Pool, Basketball Court and All of The Amenities Of Being Downtown! All Contents and Patio Furniture Are Negotiable. Call Today to Schedule Your Private Showing!

111 W Lakeshore Drive Unit 5F, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

$1,600,000

5010126 MLS

Once In A Lifetime Kelleys Island Lakefront Commercial Opportunity. Multiple Commercial and Residential Buildings on Two Parcel Lakefront Property. Included Are Four Income Producing Rental Units, One Single Family Residential Four Bedroom Ranch, Brewery/Restaurant Building and An Additional Efficiency w/ Garage. All Commercial Contents Are Negotiable To Make Transition For New Owners Simple. Most Of the Buildings On The Property Have Views Of Lake Erie. Lakefront Cottage Has 1130 Sq. Ft., Restaurant/Bar Is 3056 Sq. Ft., Main House 1670 Sq. Ft., Up & Down Apartment 800 Sq. Ft., Apartment With Garage 450 Sq. Ft. Call Today For Your Private Showing!

504 W Lakeshore Drive, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$75,000

4487753 MLS

141 x 117 (0.3787 ACRE) Lot Is Located in The Desirable Vineyard Estates Subdivision. Seller Has Completed and Received Septic Design Work and Approval For A Three Bedroom System. City Water Is Available At The Street. Call Today For Your Private Showing!

Chardonnay Drive V/L 17, Kelleys Island

Listing Courtesy of: Jason A Smith, jasononki@gmail.com With RE/MAX Above & Beyond

Selling Office: RE/MAX Above & Beyond.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity™ program of the Multiple Listing Service of Greater Cincinnati. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than our company are marked with the Broker Reciprocity™ logo (the small house as shown to the left) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This data is up-to-date as of . Copyright 2026, MLS of Greater Cincinnati, Inc. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®

Kelleys Island, Ohio Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Kelleys Island, Ohio is a village of 260 residents (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate) in Erie County. As of October 2026, 5 homes are for sale in Kelleys Island with a median list price of $189,000. Over the past 12 months, 13 homes sold at a median price of $409,900 (about $437 per square foot).

Kelleys Island housing market (October 2026)

Homes for sale	5 active listings (1 more pending)
Median list price	$189,000
Homes sold, last 12 months	13
Median sale price, last 12 months	$409,900
Median price per square foot	$437
Median days from listing to closing	82 days
New construction for sale	0 homes (see new builds)

Kelleys Island at a glance

Population	260 (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate)
County	Erie County
ZIP codes	43438
School districts	Kelleys Island Local School District

Search Kelleys Island homes by type

Kelleys Island ZIP codes

43438 - Erie County; 13 sales in the last 12 months, median $409,900

Kelleys Island school districts

Homes with Kelleys Island addresses are in the Kelleys Island Local School District. School boundaries do not always follow mailing addresses, so check the district on each listing.

Kelleys Island Local School District - about 100% of listings

New construction homes in Kelleys Island

Browse Kelleys Island new home construction, and check our special builder promotions for current rate buydowns and incentives from Ohio builders.

Kelleys Island real estate FAQ

How much does a home cost in Kelleys Island, Ohio?

As of October 2026, the median list price of the 5 homes for sale in Kelleys Island is $189,000. Over the past 12 months, 13 homes sold at a median price of $409,900.

What county is Kelleys Island, Ohio in?

Kelleys Island is in Erie County.

What ZIP codes are in Kelleys Island?

Kelleys Island homes on our site use ZIP code 43438.

What school district is Kelleys Island in?

Most Kelleys Island homes are in the Kelleys Island Local School District. Check the school district on each listing.

How fast do homes sell in Kelleys Island?

Homes that sold in Kelleys Island over the last 12 months took a median of 82 days from listing to closing, which includes the time under contract.

Can I get a cash offer on my Kelleys Island home?

Yes. Request a free, no-obligation cash offer, or ask for a market valuation to compare it with listing your home on the open market.

Ready to buy or sell in Kelleys Island? Call or text Christopher Lotte, Realtor® with eXp Realty, at (614) 983-3277. Office: 545 Metro Place South, Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017.

Ask a question Get a cash offer Builder promotions

Market statistics are calculated from MLS listings shown on this site (for-sale listings; rentals excluded) and are refreshed monthly; last updated October 2026. Population: U.S. Census Bureau Vintage 2024 estimates.