Castalia Ohio Homes for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5207268 MLS

Welcome to 3714 Gary Dr in Castalia, a well-maintained property offering a comfortable layout and versatile living spaces. Situated on a quiet street on a beautiful corner lot, this home provides a balance of privacy and convenience. Inside, you’ll find bright living areas with a functional floor plan designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen offers ample cabinet and counter space, and all kitchen appliances stay—making move-in more convenient and cost-effective. Recent updates add to the home’s overall value and efficiency, including a roof replacement in 2025, along with a newer furnace and hot water tank—helping to reduce maintenance concerns and support year-round comfort. The outdoor space includes a generously sized yard with flexibility for gardening, recreation, or relaxing. Whether used for outdoor projects or leisure, the space offers a range of possibilities. With convenient access to local amenities, services, and major routes, this property combines a practical location with a peaceful setting. Schedule your showing to experience all that this home has to offer.

3714 Gary Drive, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Stefani Collier, stefani.collier@glasshouserealty.com With Glasshouse Realty Group, LLC

Selling Office: Keller Williams Citywide.

$196,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5204486 MLS

Ideally situated in the Village of Castalia on a spacious lot that offers a sense of privacy, this inviting one-story home features exceptional updates and low-maintenance living. The open floor plan creates a welcoming flow, complemented by an updated kitchen with granite countertops, custom soft-close cabinetry, a farmhouse sink, and included appliances. The freshly painted interior enhances the home's clean, move-in-ready appeal. Additional highlights include a two-car garage, a fenced backyard, and a newer patio ideal for outdoor enjoyment. The updated bathroom showcases a beautifully tiled shower surround, adding a touch of style and comfort to this thoughtfully improved home. Sellers request highest and best offers by Thursday, April 30, 2026 at 5:00 PM. Sellers reserve the right to accept an offer at any time prior to the stated deadline.

216 Walnut Street, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer R Craig, jennycraig4homes@aol.com With Russell Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Simply Better Realty, LLC.

$255,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5203822 MLS

Charming and well-maintained home offering comfort, updates, and a peaceful setting! This 3-bedroom, 2-bath property sits on approximately one-third acre with a 2-car garage and a desirable layout including a primary suite with private bath. Recent updates include new plumbing, windows, and hot water heater, plus public water and sewer for added convenience. Enjoy the bright dining area with sliding glass doors leading to a deck, which steps down to a large concrete patio perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The backyard offers a country feel with farmland behind, creating a quiet and scenic backdrop. A shed with insulation and electric provides excellent storage or workspace. A truly clean, move-in-ready home in a desirable location!

3712 Ronald Drive, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Kerri A Hensel, kerri.hensel@simplybetterrealty.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Non-MLS Office.

$249,900

226002048 MLS

Terrific opportunity to purchase this 10,000Sf church building on 2.6 acres. Great location and building is in very good condition. The building is appx. 40' wide with 6' hallway dividing the class rooms in the educational wing. 25x40 fellowship area plus 18x40 eating/kitchen area. Sanctuary should seat 150. 30x24 garage building. This is a nice property priced to sell!

7410 Magill Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of : Ross V DiGiorgio ---- The Westwood Real Estate Co.

$195,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5171213 MLS

Welcome to this charming 2 bedroom home located on a quiet Castalia street, featuring an oversized 2 car garage plus an additional bonus garage on the adjoining extra lot. This well maintained property offers beautiful hardwood floors, stainless steel appliances and a newly refurbished bathroom. The partially finished basement provides and excellent opportunity for an office, playroom, workout area or additional living space. A new trek deck on the back overlooking the large backyard. Perfect place to sit and enjoy your morning coffee or your evening hot chocolate! This is a rare find which includes an extra parcel lot included with potential to expand, garden or enjoy more outdoor space. Don't miss out on this cozy home!

307 Oak Street, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Angie Barnicle-Masterson, angie.masterson@simplybetterrealty.com With Simply Better Realty, LLC

Selling Office: Truth First Realty.

$280,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5163573 MLS

Major price improvement of $72,000! Rare opportunity in Castalia! Nestled on nearly 7.5 acres, this one story all-brick home offers the perfect blend of space to live, work, play, and build or grow your business—truly a property with endless possibilities. The land features two large outbuildings, including one with a dedicated office space, plus a deer blind for hunting enthusiasts—ideal for hobbyists, business owners, or anyone seeking room to spread out. Inside, the open floor plan flows into a warm and inviting family room with a woodburning fireplace and sliding doors leading to a deck overlooking the beautiful acreage. The attached 2-car garage provides added convenience. Acreage, outbuildings, and a home all in one package—this is a truly rare find in Castalia.

8802 Mason Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer R Craig, jennycraig4homes@aol.com With Russell Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$439,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5149049 MLS

Updated, modern, and move-in ready this spacious 4/5 bedroom, 2.5 bath home is situated on nearly 2 acres in Castalia and offers the perfect blend of comfort and functionality. Designed primarily for one level living, the main floor features a huge primary suite with a walk-in closet and a luxurious en suite bath complete with a jetted tub, separate shower, and double sink quartz vanity. Enjoy an open eat-in kitchen with an island, perfect for entertaining, along with a formal dining room featuring a tray ceiling. The great room showcases a vaulted ceiling, fireplace, and sliding doors that lead to a covered deck and expansive private patio ideal for relaxing or hosting gatherings. The upstairs bonus room, complete with two skylights, offers versatility as a 5th bedroom, family room, home office, playroom, guest area, home gym, and more. Additional highlights include a welcoming front porch, main floor laundry room, an insulated two car attached garage with water hookup, and a concrete floored crawl space. The massive outbuilding is a standout equipped with a metal roof, concrete floor, overhead garage door, and it's both heated and cooled, making it perfect for hobbies, storage, or a workshop. Move in with confidence - this home comes with a one year home warranty, courtesy of the sellers. This rare find offers space, style, and flexibility all in a peaceful country setting. Don't miss your chance to call it home!

5310 Billings Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer R Craig, jennycraig4homes@aol.com With Russell Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$304,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5147177 MLS

Welcome to this gorgeous 3/4-bedroom, 3-full-bath ranch in the highly sought-after community of Castalia! This home has been beautifully overhauled from top to bottom, featuring brand new carpet, vinyl plank flooring, a stylish new kitchen backsplash, quartz counter tops, fresh landscaping, painted decks, and updated lighting throughout. The spacious floor plan includes an extra-large room off the back of the home-perfect as a luxurious master suite or a cozy family room-complete with a propane fireplace for those chilly Ohio winters. Enjoy two beautiful decks overlooking the .44-acre lot, plus an additional driveway and parking for all your guests. The extra-large 2-car garage offers plenty of storage. The kitchen is a chef's dream with stainless steel appliances, including a wine refrigerator, and an oversized fridge-all staying with the home! This property truly has it all-style, space, and location. Don't miss your chance to own a move-in ready home in this hot market!

6205 Bogart Road W, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Shanna M McGuckin, shannasellsohio@gmail.com With North Bay Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$346,500

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5130802 MLS

A PRIVATE RURAL RETREAT WITH MASSIVE OUTBUILDING & BLANK CANVAS INTERIOR! Dreaming of designing your own interior? Here's your chance! This quality built 3 bedroom, 3 full bath ranch home sits on a peaceful 2.62 acre lot in scenic Margaretta Township. With first-floor living on a crawl space foundation, this home is ready for your vision to come to life. This gorgeous countryside setting offers room to roam inside and out. The incredible 40x96 heated outbuilding is equipped with propane, electric and water-the perfect workshop, studio or storage space. Endless possibilities. This is a perfect opportunity for something special in a prime rural setting. Bring your design ideas & your vision and let us help you make your dream a reality. This property has a recent survey, auditors site is not correct. The current parcels of record includes: 33-00244.000 and 33-00244.001. Owner is also selling: 5214 Homegardner (duplex)-MLS 20251966 and will entertain an offer for both properties. All offers to be submitted by 12PM, Saturday June 14th.

5216 Homegardner Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Belinda D Hoffman, Callbelinda@gmail.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$80,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5126670 MLS

NEW LISTING - GROTON TOWNSHIP - MARGARETTA SCHOOLS. Priced to reflect current condition. Bring your vision and tools! This spacious 4-bedrooms, 2-bath home boasts 2,100 sq ft. of potential on a rural 1-acre lot. Central on Main Floor Only. This is your chance to invest, renovate, and create value - perfect for flippers, contractors, or anyone looking to customize a home in a rural area. Don't miss your chance to own a slice of the country with room to breathe-and room to grow. Contact listing agent for further details. Conventional or cash buyers only. Property is being sold AS IS. Seller will make no repairs or modifications. Buyer to do their own due diligence before making an offer. The property requires a new sept system. Per Erie County Health Dept The buyer will need to do the following: Obtain a permit from the Ohio EPA/ NPDES permit, then a sewage system design would need to be submitted to the Erie County Health Dept. for review and approval. Please contact listing agent directly for further questions.

9307 Portland Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Belinda D Hoffman, Callbelinda@gmail.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$200,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5108623 MLS

Welcome to Polar Bear Country! This well-maintained ranch-style home offers practical comfort and affordability in the heart of Margaretta School District. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a bright sunroom, perfect for morning coffee or evening relaxation. This home is ready for you to personalize it with your own decorative touch. With 1,248 square feet, plus the spacious 18x11 sunroom, there's room to grow, gather, or simply enjoy the ease of single-floor living. The attached one-car garage adds convenience and ample storage space. This home sits on a manageable fenced in lot in an established allotment. Whether you're starting out, slowing down, or looking for a solid real estate purchase, this home checks all the boxes. Bonus: All kitchen appliances included, washer, dryer and a 12 month home warranty included. Simple. Smart. Affordable. Schedule your private showing today and make yourself at home in Castalia.

5617 Debra Drive, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Belinda D Hoffman, Callbelinda@gmail.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$39,000

5092617 MLS

Escape to the peace and tranquility of rural living. This parcel is just under two acres located in Groton Township of Margaretta School District and in the Region of Erie County. Build your dream home with countryside vibes while still being close to modern conveniences. A space to breathe, grow and enjoy nature. All buyers must do their own diligence on all zoning and county requirements for utilities, septic and building permits. Lot dimensions are approximate, no recent survey has been completed and is the purchasers responsibility. All testing on site must be authorized/preapproved by owner. PLEASE DO NOT walk the lot without scheduling an appointment. Fencing and gates are NOT included in the sale.

9315 Portland Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Belinda D Hoffman, Callbelinda@gmail.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: Howard Hanna.

$330,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5043912 MLS

Escape to this charming country home, offering 3-4 bedrooms including a luxurious first floor en-suite. Enjoy a new shower, jet tub, and double sinks. The kitchen boasts newer appliances, and there's a convenient office space and first-floor laundry. Upstairs, find two bedrooms, a large landing, and an unfinished bonus room. The basement is divided into three sections, with a battery backup for the sump pump. Everything feels new, including plumbing, electrical, drywall, insulation, kitchen, bathroom, flooring, and the AC. Furnace has newer controls and valves. Roof 4 years old. Two-car garage. Lovely backyard complete this inviting retreat.

6717 Parker Road, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Linda Armstrong, lindaarmstrong@bex.net With RE/MAX Quality Realty

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$236,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5040337 MLS

Welcome this charming one-story home! Nestled on a sprawling nearly half-acre lot, this property offers a perfect blend of comfort and functionality. Step inside to discover a meticulously maintained interior with ceilings and several walls freshly painted, new carpet, new bathroom and kitchen flooring and water heater replaced 2022. Bask in the natural light of the sunroom, a serene oasis that seamlessly transitions to the expansive deck. Whether you're soaking up the sun or enjoying dinner, this inviting space offers endless opportunities for relaxation and entertainment. The heart of the home awaits in the spacious eat-in kitchen, where culinary dreams come to life and appliances are coming soon. Gather around the cozy fireplace in the family room, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for nights in. Huge pantry, large laundry room and an oversized two car attached garage. The crawl space was waterproofed by EverDry, around $20,000.

6723 Ridgewood Drive, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer R Craig, jennycraig4homes@aol.com With Russell Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$232,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4497273 MLS

Spacious one story home that sits on 1/2 acre. Beautiful fenced backyard. The home is across the street from Margaretta Elementary School. Roof new in 2020. Spacious kitchen with all appliances included. 1st floor laundry. 1st floor room that could be used as an office or a large storage room. Owner's suite features a walk-in closet and attached private bath. Relax & enjoy the peaceful backyard from your beautiful sunroom. Walkout basement with a fantastic workroom or additional garage. The basement has garage door access for easy storage. Entertain on the large private patio. Enjoy the 2.5 car garage that has extra room for all of your toys. There is also a shed with electric!! Great home with so many possibilities!! **Open Sunday 10/15 @ 11:00-1:00**

3905 Maple Avenue, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer H Will, jenniferwill@bex.net With RE/MAX Quality Realty

Selling Office: Russell Real Estate Services.

$240,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4495898 MLS

OPEN HOUSE SUNDAY OCT 15TH, 1:00 to 2:30. Take IMMEDIATE POSSESSION of this newly renovated one story ALL BRICK home situated on nearly 1/2 an acre in Castalia! The open kitchen offers quartz countertops and a new stainless appliance package. Main floor laundry is optional in one of the bedrooms or in the full basement (dryer vent will need installed in basement). 24 x 9.5 enclosed back porch, full basement, attached oversized two car garage with built-in cabinets and a full attic. Square footage and measurements are approximate. Seller will consider all offers up to and including Monday Oct 16, 2023 at 5PM. Seller reserves the right to accept any offer prior to deadline.

5816 State Route 101, Castalia

Listing Courtesy of: Jennifer R Craig, jennycraig4homes@aol.com With Russell Real Estate Services

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC..

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity™ program of the Multiple Listing Service of Greater Cincinnati. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than our company are marked with the Broker Reciprocity™ logo (the small house as shown to the left) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This data is up-to-date as of . Copyright 2026, MLS of Greater Cincinnati, Inc. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®

Castalia, Ohio Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Castalia, Ohio is a village of 746 residents (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate) in Erie County. As of October 2026, 1 home is for sale in Castalia with a median list price of $249,900. Over the past 12 months, 5 homes sold at a median price of $252,000 (about $179 per square foot).

Castalia housing market (October 2026)

Homes for sale	1 active listings
Median list price	$249,900
Homes sold, last 12 months	5
Median sale price, last 12 months	$252,000
Median price per square foot	$179
Median days from listing to closing	51 days
New construction for sale	0 homes (see new builds)

Castalia at a glance

Population	746 (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate)
County	Erie County
ZIP codes	44824
School districts	Margaretta Local School District

Search Castalia homes by type

Castalia ZIP codes

44824 - Erie County; 5 sales in the last 12 months, median $252,000

Castalia school districts

Homes with Castalia addresses are in the Margaretta Local School District. School boundaries do not always follow mailing addresses, so check the district on each listing.

Margaretta Local School District - about 100% of listings

New construction homes in Castalia

Browse Castalia new home construction, and check our special builder promotions for current rate buydowns and incentives from Ohio builders.

Castalia real estate FAQ

How much does a home cost in Castalia, Ohio?

As of October 2026, the median list price of the 1 homes for sale in Castalia is $249,900. Over the past 12 months, 5 homes sold at a median price of $252,000.

What county is Castalia, Ohio in?

Castalia is in Erie County.

What ZIP codes are in Castalia?

Castalia homes on our site use ZIP code 44824.

What school district is Castalia in?

Most Castalia homes are in the Margaretta Local School District. Check the school district on each listing.

Can I get a cash offer on my Castalia home?

Yes. Request a free, no-obligation cash offer, or ask for a market valuation to compare it with listing your home on the open market.

Ready to buy or sell in Castalia? Call or text Christopher Lotte, Realtor® with eXp Realty, at (614) 983-3277. Office: 545 Metro Place South, Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017.

Ask a question Get a cash offer Builder promotions

Market statistics are calculated from MLS listings shown on this site (for-sale listings; rentals excluded) and are refreshed monthly; last updated October 2026. Population: U.S. Census Bureau Vintage 2024 estimates.