Fayetteville Ohio Homes for Sale

Bring your vision and transform this property into your next investment success! With most of the home already gutted, this is an opportunity to customize the space while exploring the potential to convert it into a duplex or create a 4-bedroom home. First-time homebuyers could consider an owner-occupied investment by living in one side and renting out the other. A welcoming front porch and spacious backyard with wooded views provide added appeal. Located in Fayetteville-Perry LSD with easy access to State Route 32, this property is full of possibilities!

3591 State Route 131, Fayetteville

Courtesy of James Harris and Keller Williams Seven Hills

$400,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1897810 MLS

Picture your morning coffee in the 3-season room, string lights still glowing from last night, while mist lifts off the lake at the bottom of your lawn. Mature trees wrap the long lot in privacy, and the grass rolls right down to a quiet cove of gated Lake Lorelei. 2 private docks wait at the shore, and a 3-acre fishing lake is a short walk from your backyard. The eat-in kitchen & living room share one open stretch, and by afternoon, sunlight pours over the custom 42 cherry cabinets while the water sparkles in the windows. Original hardwoods sleep under all main-level carpet, waiting to be woken up. The finished, walkout basement has a family room + a potential 4th bedroom with bath that gives loved ones a reason to stay a little longer! Shade-seekers claim the covered patio below; sun-chasers take the raised deck, perched above it all like a private balcony. A newer whole-home generator changes storms into scenery and throws stress out the window. Unpack once and relax forever here!

1118 Stuttgart Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Logan Binkley with Ken Perry Realty, Inc.

$549,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 971266 MLS

Get ready to fall in love with this super cute, updated lakefront retreat! From the moment you arrive you'll appreciate the charm, peaceful setting, and waterfront views. The amazing covered deck is the perfect place to relax, entertain, and take in the beauty of the lake. Situated on a rare double lot with the potential to be re-parceled (subject to applicable approvals), this property has endless possibilities! Head down to the water to enjoy the adorable fire pit area. You will love the oversized garage and additional storage shed offering plenty of room for all of your lake toys. Located in the desirable gated Lake Lorelei! Don't miss your chance to own a little slice of lakefront paradise!

1058 Brunswick Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Shelley Miller and Coldwell Banker Realty

$799,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 968985 MLS

Move right in this Beautifully Updated Waterfront Home with over 100 ft of waterfrontage! This awesome Ranch offers a walk out lower level & is in Pristine Condition with a long list of Updates and Upgrades! The open floor plan offers many options for family living & entertaining. Enjoy your morning coffee in the sunroom adjacent to the primary bedroom that is also open to the living room! 3BRs on the main level plus 1 BR & study, family room with bar sink in walk out lower level. Gorgeous views of the 'mini cove' & main lake from the deck, walkout patio & multi slip dock! Truly "Turn Key", just move in and enjoy Lake Living!

599 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

$330,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 962216 MLS

Beautifully renovated home situated on 2.4 acres surrounded by trees! Walk to the beach or rental dock plus enjoy privacy in the gorgeous rear yard! 1st floor primary suite, study plus 2 bedrooms up with shared Jack & Jill bath upstairs. Just a few of the many updates include ... Updated Plumbing & Electric, New HVAC 2024, Freshly Painted, New LVP flooring & baseboards on main level, New Carpet in Primary BR, New interior doors on main level, New commode and vanity in powder room and so much more!

512 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$475,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 957443 MLS

Fabulous water front location! Enjoy wonderful lake views from the dock, deck or 14 x 14 screened porch! Relax in the living room with views of the water & warmth from the electric fireplace. 4 bedrooms, 2 full, updated baths. The full waterproofed basement offers additional living or game space plus plenty of area for storage. Lovingly cared for! Newer Furnace/Heat Pump & Water Heater.

536 Munster Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$350,250

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 954867 MLS

Dreaming of owning a new home in a Wonderful Gated Lake Community? This is the perfect choice! This new home will give you time to relax & enjoy all the amenities Lake Lorelei offers! The open floor plan offers the wonderful space to relax or entertain inside plus 2 large covered porches to enjoy outdoor living! Awesome open kitchen, dining & great room with walkout! The split bedroom offers privacy in the primary suite that features carpet, an attached full bath & walk in closet with 2 additional bedrooms & the 2nd full bath. The oversized garage adds additional storage for water toys! The quality construction with attention to details will allow you time to enjoy spring, summer, fall & winter in your new home!

742R Odenwald Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$385,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 950812 MLS

Rare find! Updated home with 3 waterfront lots totally over 1.25 acres on the 7 acre lake! Flexible floor plan with approximately 2,740 sq ft - 2 primary suites, 3 additional BRs, study & 3 full baths! Many amazing updates! New electric furnace & heat pump, 2 new windows & new gorgeous electric fireplace, installed in LR, 2 functioning jetted tubs, new garage door & opener, new deck rails, newly installed fenced yard, new shed, all new beautiful landscaping! Granite counter in Kitchen, some new flooring. Charming lake home with peaceful, private and serene setting.

1027 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$20,000

950522 MLS

Build your dream lake home and have a beautiful view of the cove & lake from your new front porch or veranda! Situated across the street from Cove A, an easy drive from the main entrance and close to the east beach! Enjoy the amenities of this wonderful gated community! 3 Lakes, 2 Beaches, a Pavilion, New clubhouse being built in 2026! Great fishing, swimming and boating!

1561 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$265,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 938546 MLS

Welcome home to this darling brick ranch home in Fayetteville, with so much to love! This renovated property has over 2200 square feet, 3BR /2 full BA, plus full walk out basement all situated on an acre lot with a huge blacktop parking area. Amish cabinets and new stainless steel appliances, granite in kitchen that walks out to large deck, basement includes laundry area (washer and dryer convey), plenty of storage area, kitchenette, full updated bathroom and bonus room. Almost everything has been touched and updated by seller including new HVAC, new HWH, 4 new glass block windows, newer roof with boot repair, new sump pump, new electrical panel, new ADT system, foundation/cellar work, new stainless steel appliances, tree removal. Separate trailer in back of property also conveys! Immediate occupancy, don't miss it!

19551 US Highway 68, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Heather McColaugh and BF Realty

Selling Office: Test Office.

$785,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 938174 MLS

Once in a generation an opportunity to own the lake home of your dreams! Over .8 acre, w/ more than 200 ft of lake frontage & next door to sandy beach on 197 acre Lake Lorelei, this striking home reflects the finest of craftsmanship. Welcoming Entrance Hall leading to cathedral ceiling Great Rm w/ wonderful WBFP opens to expansive patio area. Center island Kitchen w/ cherry cabinets, quartz countertops affords many options for informal Dining, including counter top seating & an exceptional atrium Dining area. Spacious Primary Bedroom w/ sparkling adjoining Bathroom. 2 other Bedrooms w/ full Bathroom. Every room offers lake views & access. Exceptional front to rear ceramic tiled Garden Rm w/ both lake & garden views (potential 4th Bedroom). Convenient, separate Utility Room. Big Screened-in Porch. Detached, cedar-paneled 2 car Garage designed to accommodate a boat — Garage converts to a fantastic party barn! Professionally landscaped grounds w/ charming Gazebo! Truly the best!

1310 Mann Cove, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Sean Pleiman and Irongate Inc.

Selling Office: Test Office.

$299,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 936832 MLS

This is a Fannie Mae HomePath Property. Fully Renovated 3BR/2BA ranch in Fayetteville. Beautifully updated inside and out, this 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch home offers a move-in ready opportunity situated on over 1 acre. Upgrades include a new roof, windows, siding, gutters, downspouts, updated storage shed, & sealed driveway. Interior features a brand new kitchen, shaker cabinets w/ soft close, granite countertops w/ counter bar, & stainless steel appliances. Both bathrooms are fully renovated w/ custom tile. Additional upgrades include new doors, trim, hardware, light fixtures, LVP & new carpet throughout. Updated electric service & panel, new furnace, A/C, & water heater. With an excellent location, updated mechanics, & stylish finishes, this one checks all the boxes, don't miss out!

1816 N Woodland Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Kurt Polter and Prodigy Properties

Selling Office: Plum Tree Realty.

$342,775

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 935353 MLS

Welcome to your future dream home! This to-be-built custom home offers perfect blend of modern design, comfort and convenience. This 3 bed 2 bath ranch style home will be nestled on a peaceful 1 acre lot less than a mile from Indian Creek Wildlife Area with public sewer and water. Fayetteville Perry Local Schools. Whether your looking for privacy, space to entertain, or room to grow this home provides it all. Enjoy the tranquility of country living without sacrificing accessibility as this property offers easy access to schools, shopping and major roadway.

4864 Murray Corner Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Kelly Lewis and Huff Realty

Selling Office: Test Office.

$305,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 933359 MLS

Dreaming of owning a home in a Wonderful Gated Lake Community? This is the perfect choice! A NEW home will give you the time to relax & enjoy all the amenities Lake Lorelei has to offer! This Ranch offers a large multi purpose great room or /LR- dining room combo with walkouts, adjacent kitchen with breakfast nook, 3 BRs plus a study. Split bedroom floor plan! Upgraded luxury vinyl flooring in the great room & kitchen, custom kitchen cabinets, solid surface counters, carpeted bedrooms, tile surround tub showers & best of all ? quality construction! Estimated completion? Just in time to launch your boat and enjoy the summe

185 Dortmund Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$247,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 933445 MLS

Wonderful 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch, includes 2 additional lots, totaling just over an acre! Situated just across the street & offers sneak peeks of the lake! Newer roof, water heater, bay window, updated baths, attached & detached garage. Just waiting for your personal cosmetic updates! Enjoy all the amenities of the Lake Lorelei community! This gated community offers 3 lakes & 2 beaches.

1741 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$15,000

932427 MLS

Just a short walk to rental docks, West beach and Pavilion! Build your dream home on this great lot and enjoy all the amenities this lake community offers! 3 lakes, 2 beaches, play areas, rental docks. Boating, swimming and great fishing!

396 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$350,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 926321 MLS

Meticulously designed 3 bed/3 full bath modern ranch home w/ a finished basement showcases brick accents that elevate its curb appeal and a welcoming covered front porch that sets the stage for what's inside. Nestled within the serene Lake Lorelei gated community, this property offers access to the tranquil lake, ideal for those seeking a retreat from the hustle and bustle. Step through the front door & find yourself in a grand living/dining area, where soaring cathedral ceilings & abundant natural light enhance the sense of space. The heart of the home features a beautiful gas fireplace, perfect for gathering around during chilly evenings, adding both warmth and a cozy ambiance. The large eat-in kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's dream, w/ ample counter space, generous cabinet storage, & an inviting layout that makes meal prep a breeze. Whether hosting festive gatherings or enjoying quiet mornings, this kitchen adapts to all your needs. Retreat to the luxurious primary bedroom, a true sanctuary featuring sliding glass doors that lead to the back patio. The en suite bathroom is akin to a private spa, boasting a double vanity, walk-in glass surround shower, massive walk-in closet, & a soaking tub designed for ultimate relaxation. Extend your living & entertaining space to the finished basement, a versatile area that meets an array of needs from a home theater or gym to a guest suite, complete with a full bath & laundry room (additional hookup in the main floor hallway, if needed). This level also offers substantial extra storage space to keep your home organized and clutter-free. Outdoors, the maintenance-free composite deck, patio, & large utility shed enhance your lifestyle, providing perfect spots for summer BBQs and secure storage for tools and toys. This home is not just a living space but a place where comfort meets functionality, offering great amenities to enrich your everyday life. Call today to schedule your tour and start making memories!

14 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Sue E Bowman and Howard Hanna Real Estate Serv

Selling Office: Falgner Realty, LLC.

$3,000

925516 MLS

Enjoy life in a wonderful gated lake community - 3 lakes, 2 beaches, rental docks and lots of fun activities! HOA fees of $640 per year. Great location, close to the dam on the east side of the community and easy access to the east beach and rental docks.

1676 Oder Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

1564 Fredrick Strasser Drive, Fayetteville

$20,000

903999 MLS

Build your Dream Home on this cleared and level lot situated close to the main entrance and east beach! Just across the street from a cove with rental docks. Great lot with space for recreation and fun! An adjoining lot is also available for purchase. With ownership and as a member you can launch your boat, swim, fish, ski ...enjoy the amenities Lorelei ...3 lakes, 2 beaches, a pavilion plus all the activities our community offers. Adjacent Lot or sale

1564 Fredrick Strasser Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

1596-1597 Fredrickstrasser Drive, Fayetteville

$36,500

914591 MLS

Outstanding opportunity to own 2 lots that back to a rec area and are within walking distance to a cove with rental docks. Enjoy the wonderful community of Lake Lorelei with 3 lakes, 2 beaches an pavilion.

1596-1597 Fredrickstrasser Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$185,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 922765 MLS

Move in, relax & enjoy views of the lake out your back door & deck! This wonderful, updated ranch offers 2 bedrooms 1 bath & is just a short walk to the beach, play areas, lake and pavilion. A fenced portion of the rear yard is perfect for young children and pets!

611 Manheim Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$15,000

907505 MLS

3 Lots - Approximately 1 acre! Includes 968 Halle Dr. L-shaped so you have many options for building and fun! Each lot is 75 x 200. Enjoy all the amenities of this special gated lake community! 3 Lakes, Beach, Pavilion, Clubhouse and play areas!

979-980 Krupp Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Century 21 RedSun.

$4,000

902282 MLS

This level and cleared lot is ready for you to build your dream home! Enjoy life in a wonderful gated lake community - 3 lakes, 2 beaches, rental docks and lots of fun activities!

744 Odenwald Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$328,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 903911 MLS

Wonderful Waterfront on the 7 acre lake-close to rental docks on main lake! Approx 2,740 sqft, 1st & 2nd flr Primary Suites + 3 additional BRS & study! Living rm w/ fireplace on 1st flr, FR on 2nd , both w/ walkouts. Kitchen w/ granite counters, SS appliances & custom island w/ butcherblock counters, storage & counter bar. Total of 3 lots - 1.25 acres w/ 180’ waterfront!

1027 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$525,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 896471 MLS

Wonderful Waterfront Ranch w/ finished walk out lower level. Great space for living & entertaining - living rm on main floor & LL family rm w/ dry bar & walkout! 2 large bedrooms will accommodate several beds or bunks, King or Queen would fit in other 2! Large multi slip dock! Oversized detached garage - perfect for cars and water toy storage!

1669 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$449,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 909311 MLS

Lake life can be yours this summer!! Custom built one owner, 4 bedroom, 3 bath home in Lake Lorelei! Enjoy essentially two homes in one! Perfect for multigenerational living, or just extra room for a lot guests! Home is extremely spacious w/ new carpet & fresh paint. Custom built covered deck is perfect for entertaining or enjoying nature. 3 Car garage, two driveways for each level/entrance of home. Located steps away from a boat dock. Seize this unique opportunity! Please view our virtual tour for more! Agent related to sellers.

376 Dusseldorf Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Loretta Williams and Lohmiller Real Estate

Selling Office: BF Realty.

$12,000

907346 MLS

Large lot with Public Sewer! Enjoy life in a wonderful gated lake community - 3 lakes, 2 beaches, rental docks and lots of fun activities! Great location, close to the dam on the east side of the community and easy access to the east beach and rental docks.

95 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$435,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 897307 MLS

Beautiful 29.28 acres, partially wooded & cleared property, as well as a fully stocked pond. Property included a spacious 3 Bedroom, 2 Full Bath Ranch home custom build in 2017. Make this outdoor oasis your own, with more than enough space to do all your preferred outdoor activities. (Please do not walk property without a Realtor.)

22119 Chaney Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Melissa Desotelle and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Heritage.

$36,000

894338 MLS

Great opportunity to own 3 lots together in the Beautiful Gated Lake Community of Lake Lorelei This property is just a short walk from the main beach,Clubhouse, picnic pavilion .These three lots back up to the current LLPOA lake office . mature shade trees Build up for a view of the water .

622-623-624 Manheim, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Shandra Doughman and Keller Williams Pinnacle Group

Selling Office: Test Office.

$131,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 903178 MLS

Calling Investors! Needs work - reports & some estimates can be provided - may need Renovation loan or cash. One of kind A Frame. View of the cove just across the street. Large, vaulted dining/great rm w/ sunken bar, 4 BRs, multiple covered decks/porches, firepit & oversized detached garage! Brand new roofs on house, porches & garage. Lot 1562 included

1563 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

1565 Frederick Strasser Road, Fayetteville

$19,000

903992 MLS

1565 Frederick Strasser Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Heritage.

$240,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 898223 MLS

This home offers so many possibilities. The main home features 2 bedrooms and 2 baths with an updated Kitchen, sunroom, a whole house fan, and a wood-burning fireplace. The separate cottage includes a living space with a wet bar, a full bath, and a one-car garage. This property includes a total of 4 lots. Lake Access can be yours with a short walk to the cove. There you can enjoy all the lake has to offer. Lake Lorelei offers many amenities, including a private beach, clubhouse, and community events, ensuring a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere. Don't miss out on this extraordinary opportunity to own a piece of Lake Lorelei paradise. Schedule your private showing today and start living the lake lifestyle you've always dreamed of!

339 Leipzig Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Angela Johnson-France and Coldwell Banker Heritage

Selling Office: Test Office.

21754 Fayetteville Blanchester Road, Fayetteville

$350,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 917589 MLS

Discover your perfect country retreat! This 8-acre property boasts a ranch-style home with hardwood floors upstairs and a large primary bathroom with double vanity. Enjoy the versatility of two kitchens, ideal for a guest suite or multi-generational living. Relax in the four-season room, with views of your private pond and country landscape. The property includes both an attached and a detached garage, perfect for storage or a workroom. New HVAC, Roof 2022, Leaf Filter 2019, Trane Furnace. All room sizes are approximate. Buyer to confirm.

21754 Fayetteville Blanchester Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Kelli Roberts and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$460,000

897720 MLS

The spot you have been waiting for! 66.57ac of rolling hardwoods plus new 24x48 barn w/ living area in Northern Brown co near Fayetteville & Lorelei. Gated drive leads back to secluded barn, fully spray foam insulated w/ concrete floor & underground electric, 10x20 overhead door w/front porch and 12x24 cabin built in one end. Good trail system w/large creek running thru property plus 7ac hayfield on the South side. Excellent Whitetail property loaded with wildlife, ready to hunt, play & enjoy!

19121 Woodward Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of G. Tyler McConnell and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$700,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 911689 MLS

WOW! Truly special log home with spectacular views of the main lake & stunning views of Sunrise! Just inside a "no wake zone" with spectacular big water views! Solid log home with 2 story addition offering 2 large Primary Suites with fabulous water views! 2nd floor primary suite offers walkout to balcony, walkout to newer enclosed 4 season room from the 1st floor primary & kitchen! Newer deck, Patio, Composite Dock!

50 Keil Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$816,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 910671 MLS

This stunning lakefront retreat offers unparalleled tranquility with breathtaking views & a private dock for endless water adventures. This property has a nice flat lot & is located in a no wake zone. There are 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths. Amenities include 2 story main floor with hardwood floors and stone fireplace, oversized custom kitchen with walk-in pantry, an expansive low maintenance deck with a screened in porch, private owners loft area, LL finished basement with fireplace, screen projector and wet bar. Quick occupancy just in time for Memorial Day.

1071 Wetzlar Cove, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Anne Wagner and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 900787 MLS

Lakeview Haven! Don't miss your opportunity to own almost 3 Acres in the gate Lake Lorelei community. 3 bed 2 bath. 4 car large pole barn w/ electric. Lake views from all front facing rooms. New Roof!!

1465 Oder Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Ragan McKinney and Ragan McKinney Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Victory + Affiliates.

$635,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 895742 MLS

Fabulous Cape Cod on double lot & 313 ft of water front! Gorgeous updates throughout! Luxury Vinyl in great room, kitchen & dining nook. Awesome kitchen – perfect for entertaining with large island, granite counters, upscale appliances, pantry & adjacent Dining nook with walkout! Stone fireplace & walkout in vaulted, beamed great room. 1st floor Primary suite with double vanity, large walkin shower. Large bedroom plus loft & full updated bath up! Partial finished lower level with dry bar & walk out to patio. Partially wooded lot with multiple docks & beautiful views of the lake!

1073 Wetzlar Cove, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$200,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 899264 MLS

Welcome Home! This 4 bed, 1.5 bath home is located in Fayetteville School District. It sits on 1 acre of land and offers many upgrades and improvements including new siding and a new roof. This cozy ranch makes you feel right at home the moment you step inside. Enjoy the peace & quiet of rural living and the large front porch to take in the beauty of the country. This property has so much to offer! Schedule a showing to see for yourself.

2271 Tucker Road, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Kelly Lewis and Huff Realty

Selling Office: Huff Realty.

$289,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 918016 MLS

One of kind A Frame with fabulous renovation! View of the cove just across the street. New Floor structure, carpet & LVP throughout! New cabinets & appliances in the newly designed kitchen. Large, vaulted dining/great room combo w/ sunken bar, 3-4 BRs, new full bath on main level, new 1/2 bath added upstairs! New water heater. Multiple covered decks & porches, firepit & oversized detached garage! Brand new roofs on house, porches & garage. Lot 1562 included.

1563 Lorelei Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Test Office.

$188,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 919437 MLS

This wonderful "in town" Fayetteville brick ranch has been lovingly cared for and updated by the same family since it was built...Charming yet spacious Living Room...opening to Dining Room area...flowing into professionally updated, fully equipped Kitchen with striking dark wood cabinetry...large, convenient Utility Room (note washer & dryer stay)...wide hallway leading to 2 generously sized Bedrooms (originally designed as a 3 Bedroom), both Bedrooms offering great closet space...2 completely updated Bathrooms - one off the Bedroom with whirlpool tub and one off the Hallway...nice Screened Porch off Kitchen and overlooking big yard...oversized 2 car Garage with Workshop plus second shed. Handsome brick fireplace in Living Room. Extensively updated throughout with beautiful woodwork and moldings, flooring, interior painting, etc. Truly a "walkable" neighborhood within short distance to shopping, schools and church. A rare opportunity to purchase such a quality home!

251 S Main Street, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Sean Pleiman and Irongate Inc.

Selling Office: Irongate Inc..

$3,000

917782 MLS

Vacant lot waiting for you new lake home! Enjoy life in a wonderful gated lake community - 3 lakes, 2 beaches, rental docks and lots of fun activities! Great location, close to the dam on the east side of the community and easy access to the east beach and rental docks.

1453 Oder Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$9,500

917779 MLS

Double lot, over 1/2 acre! Enjoy life in a wonderful gated lake community - 3 lakes, 2 beaches, rental docks and lots of fun activities! Great location, close to the dam on the east side of the community and easy access to the east beach and rental docks.

1449 Oder Drive, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Chris Behm and Comey & Shepherd REALTORS

Selling Office: Comey & Shepherd REALTORS.

$590,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 902556 MLS

This Gorgeous home features 4 Beds 3 full baths and 1 half bath and full basement! Covered back porch perfect for entertaining! Enjoy the Fenced in back yard and the 16.22 acres.

4166 State Route 131, Fayetteville

Courtesy of Ragan McKinney and Ragan McKinney Real Estate

Selling Office: Ragan McKinney Real Estate.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity™ program of the Multiple Listing Service of Greater Cincinnati. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than our company are marked with the Broker Reciprocity™ logo (the small house as shown to the left) and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. This data is up-to-date as of . Copyright 2026, MLS of Greater Cincinnati, Inc. All rights reserved. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity program of the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Real estate listings from the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the IDX logo and are provided by the Dayton Area Board of Realtors® MLS IDX Database. Information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in. Copyright© 2026 Dayton Area Board of Realtors®

Fayetteville, Ohio Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Fayetteville, Ohio is a village of 317 residents (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate) in Brown County. As of October 2026, 2 homes are for sale in Fayetteville with a median list price of $599,500. Over the past 12 months, 6 homes sold at a median price of $346,512 (about $153 per square foot).

Fayetteville housing market (October 2026)

Homes for sale	2 active listings (1 more pending)
Median list price	$599,500
Homes sold, last 12 months	6
Median sale price, last 12 months	$346,512
Median price per square foot	$153
Median days from listing to closing	56 days

Fayetteville at a glance

Population	317 (U.S. Census Bureau 2024 estimate)
County	Brown County
School districts	Fayetteville-Perry Local School District

Search Fayetteville homes by type

Fayetteville school districts

Homes with Fayetteville addresses are in the Fayetteville-Perry Local School District. School boundaries do not always follow mailing addresses, so check the district on each listing.

Fayetteville-Perry Local School District - about 100% of listings

Fayetteville real estate FAQ

How much does a home cost in Fayetteville, Ohio?

As of October 2026, the median list price of the 2 homes for sale in Fayetteville is $599,500. Over the past 12 months, 6 homes sold at a median price of $346,512.

What county is Fayetteville, Ohio in?

Fayetteville is in Brown County.

What school district is Fayetteville in?

Most Fayetteville homes are in the Fayetteville-Perry Local School District. Check the school district on each listing.

Can I get a cash offer on my Fayetteville home?

Yes. Request a free, no-obligation cash offer, or ask for a market valuation to compare it with listing your home on the open market.

Ready to buy or sell in Fayetteville? Call or text Christopher Lotte, Realtor® with eXp Realty, at (614) 983-3277. Office: 545 Metro Place South, Ste 100, Dublin, OH 43017.

Ask a question Get a cash offer Builder promotions

Market statistics are calculated from MLS listings shown on this site (for-sale listings; rentals excluded) and are refreshed monthly; last updated October 2026. Population: U.S. Census Bureau Vintage 2024 estimates.