Barnesville Ohio Homes for Sale

Barnesville Ohio Homes for Sale

$459,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 5240801 MLS
An amazing opportunity in the highly sought-after Hillcrest area in Barnesville! Built in 2012 and situated on 1.6 acres, this move-in ready ranch offers a peaceful setting just steps from town, with convenient access to St. Rt. 800 and I-70. Offering over 2,100 sq ft of living space on the main floor, the home features an open-concept kitchen and living area with a cathedral ceiling, creating a bright and welcoming space for everyday living & entertaining. The primary suite is privately situated on one side of the home and features its own full bathroom with a walk-in shower & walk-in closet. On the opposite side are 2 additional bedrooms & another full bathroom. All three main-floor bedrooms have recently been updated with new luxury vinyl flooring, and the laundry is conveniently located on the main floor as well. The finished basement adds even more living space with a large rec area, an additional bedroom and a full bathroom, perfect for guests, older kids, a home office or simply extra room to spread out. A walkway from the front of the home leads directly to the basement entrance, providing convenient separate access for guests or home business needs. Outside, enjoy two back decks, one off the main level and another off the basement, along with a 20 x 12 shed and plenty of room to enjoy the 1.6-acre property. The oversized 1120 sq ft deep bay 3 car attached garage provides ample space for vehicles, storage & hobbies. For added convenience, all switches throughout the main floor have been upgraded to smart switches. A quick golf cart ride takes you to the park, football games, the Pumpkin Festival & downtown. With St. Rt. 800 nearby providing easy access to I-70, the location is ideal for commuting, work or travel. With 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, multiple living areas, a 3 car garage and the convenience of ranch style living, this move-in ready home offers plenty of space inside & out, all while keeping you close to everything Barnesville has to offer.

35210 Kirkwood Avenue, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Samantha K Welch, samantha.welch44@outlook.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

$375,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 5236750 MLS
A true Barnesville landmark with plenty of possibilities! Locally known as "The Grange Hall,” this unique property offers the space, character, and flexibility to fit a variety of uses, whether you’re looking for a residential property, multiple apartments, a commercial opportunity, or a combination of it all. With no zoning restrictions, the possibilities are wide open for whatever vision you may have for the property. The lower level currently features a finished 2-bedroom apartment, along with the potential for 1–2 additional apartments. Much of the work is already in place, including another kitchenette and a separate room that could serve as an office or additional bedroom. There’s also an extra-large finished room with beautiful wood flooring and a half bath, offering even more options for living space, business use, recreation, or additional rental income. Upstairs, the original hardwood floors add plenty of charm and character to the large, open space. A stage, seating area, and additional half bath make this floor ideal for gatherings, events, meetings, entertainment, or a future commercial venture. Outside, the property sits on approximately 4 acres and includes the well-known “Taber Lake,” adding even more uniqueness and appeal to this already one-of-a-kind property. This property is close to Barnesville schools, local businesses, and everyday conveniences, yet the property has an out-of-town feel with plenty of space and privacy. Whether you have a specific vision in mind or are looking for a property with room to create your own, The Grange Hall is full of possibilities and ready for its next chapter.

980 Shamrock Drive, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Samantha K Welch, samantha.welch44@outlook.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

$229,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 5223130 MLS
WOW!!! This amazing attention to detail & updated 3 bedroom 1.5 bath home is one you won't want to miss in Barnesville. Beautiful stone landscaping for curb appeal around home and paver walkway. Walk up to the large covered front porch with a wood floor to sit & relax. A well lit spacious living room with a decorative fireplace that is flanked with built in cabinets, beautiful woodwork and floors and a wood staircase with decorative newel. The dining room with wood floor & chandelier is perfect for casual or formal entertaining. Updated neutral kitchen has all of your culinary needs including spacious drawers, cabinets, pantry cabinet, recessed lighting, lots of counter space for prepping, stainless appliances and it is attached to an open mudroom for convenience of carrying groceries in. A newer half bath off the mud room completes this first floor. Beautiful lit wood staircase to the second floor. An updated full bathroom using all neutral colors, newer lighting, cabinets, shower and a soaker tub. 1st bedroom has ceiling fan, wood floor and a bonus step down sunroom to use as reading, office or nursery. 2nd bedroom has ceiling fan & wood floor. 3rd bedroom is large with a huge closet, wood floor, ceiling fan and decorative fireplace. The lower level has lots of useable space which includes a workshop with bench, workout area, storage room with shelving. The laundry room includes the washer, dryer, sink, tub/shower. New deck and steps in rear for grilling and entertaining overlooks the nice sized fenced yard. One car garage in rear with new deck and steps to the upstairs storage is a plus. Newer Vinyl Siding, Furnace & Air Conditioning. Home Warranty! Come see this move in ready home today!

618 N Broadway Street, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Karen L Derosa, kderosarealtor@gmail.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

Selling Office: Harvey Goodman, REALTOR.

$299,900
5223146 MLS
Opportunities like this don't come along often! Located just outside the Barnesville corporation limits, this nearly 30 acre property offers exceptional versatility for a wide range of buyers. Whether you're looking for a commercial location, land for future residential development, a private homesite with nearly 30 acres all to yourself, or your own hunting and recreational property, this tract has the potential to bring your vision to life. Developers may see the opportunity to create multiple residential building lots, and with the property's close proximity to the corporation limits, there may be potential to extend public water and sewer services. Buyers looking for privacy can build their dream home and enjoy the beauty and seclusion of owning the entire property. The mostly wooded landscape also provides natural beauty and excellent wildlife habitat for outstanding hunting and recreational opportunities. With its convenient location just minutes from town while still offering the peace of the countryside, this property offers the best of both worlds. Large tracts of vacant land in the Barnesville area are becoming increasingly difficult to find, making this an outstanding opportunity for investors, developers, outdoor enthusiasts, or anyone looking to own a sizeable piece of property. Oil and Gas rights will not convey.

147 W Leatherwood Pike, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Samantha K Welch, samantha.welch44@outlook.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

$575,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5208901 MLS
Move right into this beautifully crafted 2022 custom-built home offering modern design, open-concept living, and peaceful acreage. Situated on 2.15 acres , with a 36x36 detached fully finished, heated, insulated garage including its own bathroom in a highly desirable and established neighborhood. This thoughtfully designed one-level home features 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths with a seamless, functional layout. The home combines the appeal of a modern home with the benefit of being fully completed and move-in ready. The open great room flows effortlessly into the kitchen and dining area, creating a bright, welcoming space anchored by quality finishes and clean, contemporary style. The kitchen is designed for both beauty and function, showcasing granite countertops, an oversized island, abundant cabinetry, walk in pantry and direct access to the main living area - perfect for gatherings large and small. The primary suite offers privacy and comfort, highlighted by en-suite bath featuring a walk-in shower, double sink vanity, and separate his-and-her walk-in closets complete with custom organization systems. The secondary full bath is situated between both the second and third bedroom for easy access. First-floor laundry adds everyday convenience, while a spacious two-car attached garage enhances functionality and storage. The full unfinished walkout basement with painted walls is already plumbed for an additional bathroom, presents exceptional opportunity for future expansion or enjoy the extra space as it is. Relax on the covered trex deck or lower patio that overlooks the yard and woods with abundant deer. Did I mention the small barn? Set up for chickens and goats with a fenced in paddock. Opportunities like this - nearly new construction with acreage, modern finishes, and thoughtful upgrades are rare. Schedule your private showing and experience the space, quality, and potential this home offers.

64568 Mt Olivett NE Road, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Susan M Hallstrom, susanhallstrom@gmail.com With Sulek & Experts Real Estate

Selling Office: The Holden Agency.

$65,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 5203002 MLS
Tucked along a quiet street in Barnesville, 117 Greenmount Ave is a true hidden gem and fixer-upper opportunity as a "Modern Vintage Home," offering the perfect blend of original character and meaningful updates. From the moment you step inside, you’ll appreciate the timeless charm you’d expect from an older home—paired with the peace of mind that comes from major improvements already completed by the current owner. Recent upgrades include all new electrical (featuring a new weather head/service entry, 200-amp panel, and updated wiring throughout), new plumbing (both supply and drain lines), updated fixtures, HVAC system, and a new hot water tank, setting a strong foundation for future improvements while preserving the home’s classic appeal. The interior offers inviting living spaces filled with natural light and a layout that flows comfortably between the living, dining, and kitchen areas—ideal for everyday living or future redesign. Outside, the manageable yard provides room to relax, garden, or entertain. Whether you’re an investor or a buyer with vision, this property presents excellent potential—especially as a possible up/down duplex conversion. Conveniently located near local amenities, schools, and parks, this home combines small-town charm with opportunity and upside.

117 Greenmount Avenue, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: John A Kazemka, johnkazemka@gmail.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC..

$165,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 5150179 MLS
Welcome to 406 S Chestnut St, a beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home in the heart of Barnesville, Ohio! This move-in ready property has been thoughtfully updated throughout, offering modern comfort paired with timeless style. Step inside to a bright and inviting interior featuring all-new flooring. The brand-new kitchen is a true highlight, boasting butcher block countertops, stylish cabinetry, and sleek finishes that make meal prep and entertaining a joy. Both full bathrooms have been completely remodeled with fresh, modern designs and updated fixtures. The layout is designed with convenience in mind, featuring a main floor primary bedroom with an attached full bath, creating a comfortable retreat. Upstairs, you’ll find two additional bedrooms and a second updated bathroom, perfect for family or guests. With a new roof, new bathrooms, new flooring, and a fully updated kitchen, this home provides peace of mind along with move-in readiness. The exterior includes a welcoming front porch and a manageable yard, offering plenty of space for relaxing, gardening, or entertaining outdoors. Located just minutes from schools, shopping, dining, and community amenities, 406 S Chestnut St combines small-town charm with modern updates. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this beautifully renovated home your own—schedule a showing today!

406 S Chestnut Street, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Chad Wilson, chad.r.wilson@exprealty.com With EXP Realty, LLC.

Selling Office: FCR Real Estate.

$250,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 5145615 MLS
Welcome to your peaceful retreat in the woods! This custom-built Amish cabin can be your turn-key Oasis, completed in 2020, sits on 6.25 private acres and offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort. Constructed using timber and wood sourced locally, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home is truly one-of-a-kind. Tucked away among mature trees, the cabin is nestled beside a meandering creek fed by a natural spring—a serene backdrop for relaxing, exploring, or enjoying nature’s quiet beauty. A brand-new walking bridge, built in July 2025, makes it easy to cross the creek, leading to your private deck overlooking the water—an ideal spot for morning coffee, relaxing, or entertaining friends. Inside, the cabin features handcrafted woodwork, a pellet stove for cozy winters, and window A/C units to keep you cool in summer. The kitchen includes all appliances, and the layout offers an efficient use of space while maintaining a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Outdoors, you'll find a two and a half-car garage, plumbed for floor radiant heating and a large shipping container for extra storage—perfect for tools, gear, or seasonal equipment. With abundant wildlife and dense forest, this property is also a hunter’s paradise. If you're searching for privacy, self-sufficiency, and a deep connection to nature, this property delivers. Mineral Rights are not owned so they will not transfer. Contact your agent today and schedule a showing!

39280 W Captina Highway, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Justin W McCrea, justinmccrearealtor@gmail.com With Sulek & Experts Real Estate

Selling Office: RE/MAX Broadwater.

$398,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 5139249 MLS
Welcome to 62239 Hillcrest Rd in Barnesville, Ohio. Step into this inviting 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home offering a blend of classic charm and modern comforts. Stunning refinished hardwood floors in a lot of the rooms, with some rooms having newer laminate flooring. With over 2,219 sq ft,, beautiful kitchen with breakfast nook, a formal dining area, a spacious living room with a fireplace and built-ins, a full basement with rec room and a workshop, plus a 2 car attached garage, this property provides excellent space for families or those seeking room to grow. There is also extra space for your items in the many walk-in closets throughout the home. Enjoy the comfort of central air and the warmth of a wood-burning fireplace on chilly evenings. The expansive 2.91-acre lot provides plenty of room to roam and outdoor enjoyment. Located in a desirable Barnesville neighborhood, this is an ideal place to call home. Also from the owner: This fantastic home features lovely Shutler Cabinets in the kitchen and 1st floor bath as well kitchen quartz countertops. Per owner it has $150,000 in renovations. The AC unit is 3 years old. Ut also has Replacement shingles. There are refinished hardwood floors. The basement has been dry locked and also the house has been power washed. The basement rec room floor was replaced this summer.

62239 Hillcrest Road, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Laney J Ross, laneyross@gmail.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

Selling Office: Harvey Goodman, REALTOR.

$365,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 5137216 MLS
Take advantage of this rare opportunity to own your own slice of heaven with this "barndominium style" home located on over 32 acres of rolling farmland just minutes from town! This property has it all - fenced pastures, green meadows, beautiful forests, a rippling creek, and even its own private well providing ample natural gas supply to the property. This home was built in 2001 and boasts tons of rustic charm nicely complemented with modern conveniences. The oversized eat-in kitchen features leathered granite countertops, a large island, ample hickory cabinets, modern appliances, and a spacious pantry. The living room has a stone fireplace with gas logs and large picture window overlooking the scenic backyard offering panoramic views. Also on the first floor are two bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a laundry/utility room. Upstairs you will find two additional bedrooms and another full bathroom. The covered porch runs the length of the home and provides stunning sunrise views where you can also relax in the hot tub and enjoy the tranquility this property offers. This hunter's paradise also has three outbuildings, a stable, and chicken coup, providing all you need to get started with farm life, or you can simply sit back and enjoy the natural beauty and seclusion of this country retreat! Mineral rights do not convey, but natural gas well to property will transfer to new owner.

33680 Township Road 2, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Ed Eberhart, edeberhart@sbcglobal.net With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

Selling Office: RE/MAX Broadwater.

$299,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 5116581 MLS
This adorable Bungalow is full of charm and offers an abundance of features. Starting with a Spectacular custom kitchen! Cabinets and Quartz counters by Tims Customs. Stainless steel appliances including a wine refrigerator ,updated lighting, and a cozy seating area. Everything throughout the house was remodeled by professionals using top notch materials. There are hardwood floors throughout first and second floors excepting the stone floors in the kitchen and baths. You won't want to leave the Renovated Master suite on the 2nd floor, which contains its own sitting area and custom Bathroom. The updates do not stop there, the basement was renovated as well Maximizing the space. A media room which will come complete with mounted projector and screen, and a added area with a built-in lofting bed. There is a quiet study in the basement which could be used as a play room, office ect.. a half bath and laundry complete the lower level with loads of storage space. Are you looking for a house with a 4 season room well look no further, this room is most inviting .Other updates include poured driveway, a Mini barn which has been used as a studio, a two car detached garage and a extra parcel bringing this property to a half of an acre, while adding a lovely area for a firepit. Owner will remove the playset and basketball hoop if new owner does not want them. Sellers do not own the mineral rights.

915 Bond Avenue, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Susan M Hallstrom, susanhallstrom@gmail.com With Sulek & Experts Real Estate

Selling Office: Harvey Goodman, REALTOR.

$234,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 5099811 MLS
Welcome to 33661 Dog Hollow Rd in Barnesville! If it is country living and privacy you are looking for, this is the place for you. This 4 bedroom, 2 full bath home is nestled on 2.66 acres surrounded by nature including mature trees and 2 springs, giving you that peace and relaxation you are looking for. You can enjoy the beautiful views or the sound of the rain from the porch swing under the nicely covered front porch. This property also includes 2 storage sheds, perfect for your lawn mowers or ATV, a 1-2 car detached garage that provides space to park your car and an area for a workshop, plus there is a nice barn with tack room to keep your smaller farm animals like pigs, goats, sheep, chickens, rabbits, mini pony, etc (current fencing/post/stalls will be removed). As you enter the 1684 sq. ft. home, you are greeted by a spacious living room where you will cherish many family moments throughout your years here. Off of the living room you have the dining area and kitchen with newer back splash, a full bath that has a newer vanity, and a laundry/utility area. As you walk upstairs, you have freshly painted walls heading upstairs, in the hallway, plus in some of the 4 spacious bedrooms. The upstairs bathroom has many updates that include a beautiful vanity/mirror and flooring. Also upstairs you have a whole house venting system. You will have all the closet space you will ever need in this home. The home is move in ready with all the major upgrades already done for you with the furnace and A/C installed in 2024, newer metal roof on the house portion (not the porch) in 2022 - tin in garage for the porch roof and garage, plus the home is wired for a full house generator. The home is located 1.5 miles from St Rt 800 and just 10-15 from the town of Barnesville and everything you would need including parks, the community pool, schools, restaurants, and shopping. Call for your personal tour today of this beautiful, serene property before it is gone.

33661 Dog Hollow Road, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Amber Kralovic, amberk06@gmail.com With Harvey Goodman, REALTOR

Selling Office: The Holden Agency.

$735,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 5092356 MLS
Welcome to this impeccable executive home. The open floor plan offers a harmonious blend of modern luxury and functionality. This property features 4 bedrooms , 4 full baths and is certain to please with its quality construction, abundance of natural light, and beamed cathedral ceilings. The main floor includes a fabulous great room with stone woodburning fireplace, a custom kitchen with gorgeous cabinetry, pantry, granite counter tops and huge island with seating. The first floor primary bedroom features a en suite with custom walk in shower that is heated with a heat lamp and bench seating, double sinks a vanity area and walk in closets. For convenience The laundry room is located in this area. There are two other bedrooms and another full bath on the main floor. Plenty of room for entertaining with two huge welcoming back porches which overlook the serene back yard. The open staircase leads to the Lower level which features a 42x26 family room with space for office and exercise a 4th bedroom with walk in closet and the homes 3rd full bath bathroom. Beyond the sliding barn door is ample custom built-in storage , utility area and a crafting space. The walk out onto the lower patio is ready for your hot tub and includes a firepit area. Whole house generator, attic fan,400 Amp electric, leaf guards on all gutters, Hot water circulating pump and Oversized 2 car attached garage. The 36 x 40 heated building is every mans dream space. It is insulated with spray foam, houses the 4th full bath with full size washer / dryer, a kitchen area and room for multiple vehicles . The dog door allows mans best friend to enter the building or roam the fenced yard, attached to the building is a covered roof area ideal for extra storage or a covered area for animals. Adorable she shed and 1.84 acres . This is an amazing property boasting both Modern style and comfort. Agents pre- qualified buyers only please.

37250 Harrys Ridge Road, Barnesville

Listing Courtesy of: Susan M Hallstrom, susanhallstrom@gmail.com With Sulek & Experts Real Estate

Selling Office: EXP Realty, LLC..

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Barnesville Ohio Homes for Sale

Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Barnesville Ohio? Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any Barnesville, OH home for sale or to sell your Barnesville Ohio home! As Realtors specializing in the Barnesville area, we can take care of all of your Barnesville OH real estate needs including buying pre-existing homes, new construction homes, condominiums, land, commercial and multi-family homes in Barnesville Ohio. We can also help you find distressed properties in Barnesville including HUD Homes, Short Sales and REO Bank Foreclosures. If you need help financing a home in Barnesville, we have access to some of the best lenders that service the Barnesville Ohio area, including lenders that offer credit repair to buy a home and work with home builders in and near the Barnesville area to help you build your home while building up your credit. If you are going to buy or sell a home in Barnesville Ohio, then be sure to Call or Text (614) 683-5116 Today! We are a real estate team specializing in the Barnesville, OH area! Displayed are homes for sale in Barnesville, OH, a city located in Ohio. These Barnesville Listings are updated every 15 minutes from the Barnesville MLS.