44611 Ohio Distressed Sale Homes for Sale

OPEN HOUSE: Saturday September 19th 12:00pm - 1:00pm. Prime opportunity to purchase a location that has been a long-time community staple, formerly known as the Trading Post Convenience Store and Cafe. The real estate features a brick store-front building with an open-concept layout offering ample retail space, checkout counter, deli, and commercial kitchen with ventilation hood and fire suppression system. The main retail level also includes office space, a spacious storage and utility room, customer restrooms, and a private restroom. On-site you will find convenient customer parking. The back portion of the building includes a second story with a separate exterior entrance. This space has been laid out for an apartment and additional storage. While the second-floor area is unfinished, it is framed and roughed in, providing additional potential for the new owner. Numerous improvements and upgrades, including to the mechanical systems, have been completed in recent years, making this property ready to continue as a convenience store, restaurant, bakery, or other venture. The adaptable layout offers a good variety of possibilities. Come see all that this one has to offer! A non-refundable down payment due on the day of auction with balance due in 45 days. A buyer’s premium will be added to the high bid to determine the final contract price. Selling As-Is. Buyer to make any desired inspections prior to auction and arrange financing if needed. Announcements on sale day take precedence over all previous advertising. Store & Restaurant Equipment; Trade Fixtures; Remaining Inventory and more will be auctioned immediately following the real estate.

13630 County Road 100, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Nicholas J DeFelice, nickdauctions@gmail.com With Donald K. Gant Realty

5237959 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 13: 5.2 acres of mostly open and some wooded land with approx. 304’ of frontage on SR 39.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237955 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 12: 7.54 acres of mostly open and some wooded land as well as a pond. Approx. 350’ frontage on SR 39.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237944 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 11: 8.15 acres of open land with approx. 624’ of frontage on SR 39.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237939 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 10: 5.4 acres of open land with 447’ of frontage on CR 51 and approx. 520’ of frontage on SR 39.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237938 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 9: 11.73 acres of open land with a pond. Approx. 659’ frontage on CR 51. This parcel will sell subject to a cemetery easement, prior to closing.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237935 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 8: 5.6 acres of open land with approx. 267’ of frontage on CR 51.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237928 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 7: 7 acres of open land with approx. 304’ of frontage on CR 51.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237926 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 6: 6.75 acres of open land with 377’ of frontage on CR 51

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237919 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 5: 5 acres of open land with approx. 382’ of frontage on CR 51.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237915 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 4: 5 acres of open land with approx. 325’ of frontage on CR 51.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

5237913 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 3: 5 acres of open land with approx. 143’ of frontage on CR 51.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

7 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5237908 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 2: 7.38 acres with 395’ of frontage on CR 51 that includes a newer 2023 well-built Amish home that offers almost 3,000 sq ft of living area. On the main floor of the home is the kitchen with a large dining area along with a large living area and sewing nook. Also located on the main floor is one bedroom and a full bathroom. The upstairs of the home is unfinished but is insulated and framed in for an additional 6 bedrooms. Downstairs features a full walkout basement that has 1 bathroom and a laundry area. Outside of the home is a well-built bank barn built in 2022. The barn includes 2 tie stalls and 6 box stalls. The barn offers an A-Framed upper level making for spacious hay storage etc. The home has a spring fed water supply (from developed spring on parcel 9) with a private septic system.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

6 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5237898 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built and maintained Amish homes along with lots of open tillable land and excellent building sites. Parcel 1: 6.74 acres with 546’ of frontage on CR 51 with home and buildings. Offering a good 6-bedroom 2-bathroom Amish home built in 1995 with 2500+ sq ft of living area. Inside the home on the main floor, you will find a kitchen and dining area with a walk-in pantry along with a spacious living room and sewing nook. Also on the main floor is 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom. The upstairs of the home consists of 5 additional bedrooms and a large landing area. Downstairs you will find a full walk-out basement that offers an additional full bathroom as well as a summer kitchen, canning area, and laundry area. On the outside of the home is a 40’x72’ machinery pole shed with concrete floors. Also found on Parcel 1 is a nice sized hand-hewn constructed bank barn with 7 tie stalls, an attached straw and loafing shed, as well as a lean-to/feed room. The final improvement on Parcel 1 is the 36’x68’ 2-story shop with block foundation and a lower-level walkout. The home has a private septic system and 2 water wells. The first well supplies the house and the second for the bank barn.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

10 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 5237885 MLS

An excellent 86.5-acre farm split into 13 parcels offering 2 well-built Amish homes, open tillable land, ponds, and excellent building sites. Parcel 1: 6.74 acres with 546’ frontage on CR 51, featuring a 6-bedroom, 2-bath Amish home built in 1995 with 2,500+ sq. ft. Main floor includes kitchen/dining area, walk-in pantry, living room, sewing nook, bedroom, and full bath. Upstairs offers 5 additional bedrooms and a large landing. Full walk-out basement includes second bath, summer kitchen, canning area, and laundry. Improvements include a 40’x72’ machinery pole shed with concrete floors, hand-hewn bank barn with 7 tie stalls, attached straw/loafing shed and lean-to/feed room, plus a 36’x68’ 2-story shop with block foundation and lower-level walkout. Home has private septic and 2 water wells, second serving the barn. Parcel 2: 7.38 acres with 395’ frontage on CR 51, featuring a 2023 Amish home with nearly 3,000 sq. ft. Main floor includes kitchen, dining/living areas, sewing nook, bedroom, and bath. Upstairs is insulated and framed for 6 additional bedrooms. Full walk-out basement includes bath and laundry. A 2022 bank barn has 2 tie stalls, 6 box stalls, and spacious A-framed hay storage. Home has private septic and spring-fed water from a developed spring on Parcel 9. Parcel 3: 5 acres open, 143’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 4: 5 acres open, 325’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 5: 5 acres open, 382’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 6: 6.75 acres open, 377’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 7: 7 acres open, 304’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 8: 5.6 acres open, 267’ frontage on CR 51. Parcel 9: 11.73 acres open with pond and 659’ frontage on CR 51. Subject to cemetery easement prior to closing. Parcel 10: 5.4 acres open, 447’ frontage on CR 51 and 520’ on SR 39. Parcel 11: 8.15 acres open, 624’ frontage on SR 39. Parcel 12: 7.54 acres mostly open with some woods and pond, 350’ frontage on SR 39. Parcel 13: 5.2 acres mostly open with some woods, 304’ frontage on SR 39.

6206 County Road 51, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5226780 MLS

ONLINE ONLY AUCTION – Bidding begins ending 8/31/26 5PM. INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY!! The main level features 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, an eat-in kitchen, living room, laundry area, and a full unfinished basement. Utilities include natural gas heat and public water/sewer. The upper-level apartment offers 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, a kitchen, living room, and a laundry/office area, with electric baseboard heat. Home was a single family and has stairs still intact to be easily converted. Whether you're expanding your rental portfolio or looking for an income-producing property with tenants already in place, this is an opportunity worth considering.

9071 Second Street, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Junior E Miller, jr@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

$178,750

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5216662 MLS

Online Only auction ending July 7th @ 6 PM: Quite the opportunity! Situated on 6.12 acres on a quiet dead-end road, this property offers a country setting with plenty of potential. The home, built in 1977, features 1,184 sq. ft. of living space with 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, kitchen, living room, and a full basement. Outbuildings include a 25’x40’ shop along with a couple smaller sheds, providing ample storage and workspace. Utilities include water well, septic, and electric. Adding to the appeal, the home and outbuildings are packed with tools, antiques, household items, and all kinds of miscellaneous treasures — and everything stays with the property. A unique opportunity where you never know what you may find!

13171 Private Road 231, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Timothy A Miller, tim@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

Selling Office: Non-Member.

$175,000

5032148 MLS

Auction is Ending Thursday, May 16th, 2024, at 6:00 PM. Looking to purchase property in Holmes County? Finding an existing home or a suitable plot for building can be quite challenging. However, here are two attractive options: two 6+ acre lots, centrally positioned between Millersburg, Wooster, and Loudonville, just east of Nashville. These parcels blend open land and wooded areas, complete with a creek that meanders through them. Access to both lots is provided via a 50-foot common access off of Township Road 219. This is a rare opportunity to own a versatile piece of land in a desirable location.

Township Road 219, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Timothy A Miller, tim@kaufmanrealty.com With Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC.

Selling Office: Kaufman Realty & Auction, LLC..

$26,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 5022712 MLS

Great opportunity to buy this fixer upper located in Knox Township in Holmes County, OH and coming with 2 parcels totaling just over an acre of land. The all one story home has 600 sq. ft. Building in poor condition and boarded with no access.

4565 Township Road 222, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Aaron M Brailer, aaron.brailer@rhss.com With RealHome Services and Solutions, Inc.

Selling Office: Owens Real Estate Firm, Inc..

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4489019 MLS

Remodeled in 1980. 1st floor laundry, L-shaped rear deck bi-level 30x80 & 10x12 w/ extraordinary view of property. Lushly landscaped. Sunroom adjacent to kitchen. 6.5x11.6 walk-in closet in bedroom 2. Electric wall heater in Master bedroom. Vinyl replacement windows. Whole house generator. Oak kitchen cabinetry w/ peninsula & built-in desk. No heat to sunroom (10x10). Spring and septic. Fireplace in living room/dining room (propane). Detached 2-car garage-600 sq. ft. Detached pole barn 360 sq. ft. Water & electric to barn. Stair lift chair can stay.

14344 Shreve Road, Big Prairie

Listing Courtesy of: Holly Waldenmyer, hwaldenmyer@live.com With McInturf Realty

Selling Office: Home Equity Realty Group.

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

44611 Ohio Distressed Sale Homes

Search all Distressed Sale Homes in 44611 Ohio. These 44611 Distressed Sale Homes property details include large photos, local school info, tours, maps, street view and more in 44611 OH.

Call or Text (614) 683-5116 to schedule a showing on any 44611 Ohio Distressed Sale Homes Today!