Blue Crab Key Homes for Sale

Blue Crab Key Homes for Sale

$288,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 2026005591 MLS
Welcome to Pine Island’s best-kept secret – Blue Crab Key! This private, secluded community is surrounded by water on three sides, giving it a true island feel. This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom townhome is being sold TURNKEY furnished — just bring your toothbrush and start living the dream. Inside, you'll find a gorgeous remodeled kitchen featuring new stainless appliances, granite countertops, and soft-close cabinetry. The home has been freshly painted with brand-new carpeting upstairs, impact-resistant windows throughout, a new metal roof, and new spray foam insulation, with all assessments already paid. A brand-new A/C system adds even more value and comfort. Both spacious bedrooms offer private en-suite bathrooms, creating a perfect layout for privacy or guests. Step onto your screened lanai, which can also be closed in with impact glass to become a Florida room, and take in the breathtaking views of the water and mangroves. This is a true nature lover’s paradise, home to abundant wildlife including ospreys and eagles. Enjoy endless kayaking, boating, and fishing opportunities with direct Gulf access through Matlacha Pass to Charlotte Harbor — you can be in Boca Grande Pass in just minutes! Blue Crab Key offers an amazing list of amenities, including two heated pools, two spas, tennis and pickleball courts, a putting green, a clubhouse, an observation deck, boat and kayak storage, a community boat ramp, and docks. Property owners are entitled to a boat slip, available on a first-come, first-served basis. Don’t miss your opportunity to own a piece of paradise at Blue Crab Key — schedule your private showing today!

5261 Blue Crab Circle Unit 5, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of Marzucco Real Estate

Selling Office: .

$328,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 2025026107 MLS
This is one of Pine Islands most unique, well-maintained, sought after developments. As you drive up and over the bridge into Blue Crab Key, the peaceful, close-knit feel of this tropical island community is immediately apparent. Enjoy quiet evenings relaxing on your lanai or front deck. Spend time socializing at one of the two pools areas with whirlpool spas, or the pickleball courts. This unit for sale offers a gorgeous view overlooking the mangroves and canal. With Matlacha Pass in the background you’re just minutes from some of the best fishing in the world as you head out to Charlotte Harbor. The lanai is fully glassed in for comfortable air-conditioning year-round. The high-impact windows and doors are a wonderful bonus. Inside you have two spacious bedrooms, with en-suite bathrooms, and an open floor plan. Another standout feature is the extended storage unit on the first level, perfect for kayaks, fishing poles, bikes, boat equipment, and more, with all shelving included. The excellent amenities include two pools, two whirlpools, pickleball as well as tennis courts, and a putting green, clubhouse and an observation deck. Boaters have everything you need with boat and kayak storage, a community boat ramp, and docks available on a first-come, first-serve basis. With the canal and docks right outside the back door you can easily view your boat and enjoy access for loading, unloading, and rinsing after a day on the water. To top it all off, the HOA fees are the lowest on the island! Blue Crab Key is centrally located to make it much faster and easier to get on and off island. This home is being sold furnished, making it truly move-in ready.

5301 Blue Crab Circle Unit 4, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

$300,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 2026000576 MLS
Unlock your private oasis and discover a perfectly balanced life between tranquility, outdoor adventure, and a vibrant community. Imagine waking up to the gentle whispers of nature, nestled amidst 25 sprawling acres of your own private paradise. This beautifully renovated condo offers the perfect place for unwinding on your secluded lanai. A new 2024 air conditioner ensures year-round comfort, a durable metal roof provides lasting protection, and energy-efficient blown-in insulation keeps your utility bills low. The well-designed floor plan boasts two on-suites upstairs, a half bath on the main floor, and ample space to relax. You'll find beautiful appointments throughout, including bamboo flooring, updated interior doors, sleek counter-height vanities, and convenient upstairs laundry. Whip up yummy delights in the well-appointed kitchen featuring Kraft Maid cabinets, granite countertops, and top-of-the-line stainless steel LG appliances. The Extended storage unit is air-conditioned, upgraded with separate 220v electric service, a utility sink with hot and cold water, and a whole-house water filter system. This versatile space can also be transformed into your dream workshop! Shared amenities like heated pools, hot tubs, tennis and pickleball courts, and a private boat ramp become an extension of your backyard, offering opportunities for friendly competition and social interaction. Your private backyard oasis extends to a boat dock. Launch your boat or kayak for a tranquil exploration of the surrounding waterways, or venture further and navigate to Charlotte Harbor or the stunning Gulf of Mexico, renowned for its world-class fishing. This condo isn't just a home; it's your gateway to a life well-lived.

5221 Blue Crab Circle Unit B4, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of John R. Wood Properties

Selling Office: .

$285,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 224039142 MLS
PRICE DECREASE - HUGE This is one terrific buy for personal use or investment. Nothing has been spared in this Blue Crab Condo - from the view - furnishings (all included) top of line appliances extra room carpeted with AC for office -den etc. As you enter the view is peaceful and beautiful - the lanai looks over landscaped area from the insulated sliders -and screens with 11 inches of insulation so can be used year round. A large TV with fireplace is in the living area large sofa that reclines and charges your phones. New appliances - washer dryer- top of the line refrigator dishwasher. All of the baths have updated vanities,custom mirrors and built in soap dispensers, new toliets, walk in showers in both baths that are tiled. Bedrooms have Califorinia closets and 55 " TV's. Beautiful hard wood floors on 2nd level - tile on first. And there is more - the storage area has been turned into another room with cupboards, new refrigator, AC designed for office/den etc. The patio on lower level looking out on beautiful gardens the seller designed . Boat launch and great fishing awaits you at this lovely community. Blue crab has two updated pools with spas, clubhouse, tennis and pickle ball. Their own private sewer system. Boat docks, launch area with secure storage for boats and RV's. All buildings have new metal roofs and all buildings are being repainted. See the coverage of the HOA - includes so much. The green area at Blue Crab is the best in this private quite setting. Do not miss out on this one.

5481 T#5 Blue Crab Circle Unit 5, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of Century 21 Sunbelt Realty

Selling Office: .

$250,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 224104595 MLS
Welcome to your serene oasis in Bokeelia, nestled on the beautiful and tranquil Pine Island—Florida’s best-kept secret! This tastefully renovated condo at Blue Crab Key offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and natural beauty. Boasting new hurricane windows, new flooring, and new appliances, this unit was thoughtfully updated in 2022. The building itself has a new roof, and all assessments have been paid, making it move-in ready for you. Step onto your screened lanai to take in breathtaking sunrises and enjoy peaceful evenings overlooking Pine Island Creek, surrounded by lush mangroves teeming with avian life and vibrant estuaries. This property is a nature lover’s paradise, offering unparalleled kayaking, boating, and fishing opportunities. With direct Gulf access through Charlotte Harbor or Matlacha Pass, adventure awaits just outside your back door. Blue Crab Key is a highly desirable community, spanning 25 acres with just 111 units. Residents enjoy an array of amenities, including two heated pools, hot tubs, tennis/pickle-ball courts, a putting green, boat and kayak storage, a community boat ramp, and docks. Property owners are also entitled to a boat slip, available on a first-come, first-served basis. Inside, the well-designed floor plan features two master suites upstairs and a spacious main floor with a half bath, perfect for hosting family and friends. Additional upgrades include a new metal roof, spray foam insulation, hurricane-impact sliders on the lanai, and impact windows throughout. If you’re seeking a low-maintenance property with modern upgrades in a quiet and picturesque setting, this is the place for you. Don’t miss this opportunity to own your slice of paradise on Pine Island!

5271 Blue Crab Circle Unit 5, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of SanCap Gateway Realty

Selling Office: .

$290,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 225005117 MLS
** HUGE PRICE ADJUSTMENT!! WATERFRONT IN BOKEELIA FOR UNDER $300,000!! SELLER HIGHLY MOTIVATED - BRING ALL OFFERS** New range in kitchen! The best of the pristine beauty of Bokeelia on Pine Island can be enjoyed as you sip your favorite beverage from the comfort of your screened balcony directly overlooking miles of preserved mangrove forest. The fully pocketed sliders open up to bring the outdoors into the living room. This sunny, end-unit, elevated home with new metal roof sits directly on a wide canal that leads without bridges to Charlotte Harbor and the Gulf beyond, providing that alluring island boating lifestyle and lots of kayaking venues to explore. Unit is elevator-ready or keep the walk-in pantry for massive amounts of storage. Carefree laminate flooring throughout makes for easy cleaning, half bath on the 1st floor keeps your bedroom baths private, stacked washer/dryer on the top floor saves you steps, the ceiling fans keep you cool, and the interior sprinkler system keeps your home safe. Large work room/storage room with pegboards, miles of shelving, and mini-fridge is on the ground floor. Use the carport to house 2 cars in tandem or one car and ground floor open patio overlooking the canal where birds play and fish jump. This home comes fully furnished with two Primary ensuite bedrooms upstairs - one with double trundle bed and bidet, stunning original artwork, dishes, appliances, bicycle, fishing gear, and more. All you need to bring is a toothbrush. The community of Blue Crab Key, conveniently located just a short drive from the center of Pine Island, offers everything you could want for your Florida lifestyle: TWO heated pools, tennis/pickleball courts, clubhouse, boat ramp, boat docks, putting green, and more. **Information is expected to be accurate but Buyers should always perform their own due diligence.**

5331 Blue Crab Circle Unit J1, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Florida

Selling Office: .

$425,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 224084949 MLS
Escape to this peaceful 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath condo at Blue Crab Key, Pine Island—the ultimate coastal retreat. Just a short drive from Fort Myers, this condo offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, resort-style amenities, and easy access to world-class fishing and boating. Positioned along Pine Island Creek, the condo provides direct access to the water with a community dock. Enjoy kayaking, boating, or fishing right from your doorstep. The screened lanai invites you to relax and take in serene views of mangroves and wildlife, creating a calming backdrop for morning coffee or evening sunsets. Inside, the condo has been freshly painted and features new flooring and stainless steel appliances, offering a contemporary feel throughout. The bright and open floor plan makes it easy to entertain, while the master suite boasts panoramic water views, a walk-in tiled shower, and dual vanities for added comfort. Blue Crab Key is known for its lush, green surroundings and extensive amenities, including two sparkling pools with hot tubs, tennis and pickleball courts, a clubhouse with grilling facilities, and nearly 20 acres of landscaped green space. Boaters will love the onsite boat storage, private boat ramp, and over 30 boat docks, all with easy access to Pine Island Sound, Matlacha Pass, and surrounding islands. Additional features include newly installed metal roofs throughout the community, no current assessments, and a versatile storage space beneath the unit, perfect for storing boating gear and bikes. With its proximity to Fort Myers and the peaceful lifestyle Pine Island offers, this condo is the perfect getaway for anyone looking to enjoy fishing, boating, and relaxing in a serene environment. Come experience the charm of Blue Crab Key—schedule your viewing today and make this waterfront retreat your own!

5331 Blue Crab Circle Unit J2, Bokeelia

Listing Courtesy of RE/MAX Harbor Realty

Selling Office: .

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.

Blue Crab Key - Bokeelia Florida Homes for Sale

Search all homes for sale in Blue Crab Key, Bokeelia Florida. View photos, prices, maps and more for Blue Crab Key in Bokeelia FL.

Call or Text (239) 880-8873 to schedule a showing on any home in Blue Crab Key Today!