Refine Search
Sort by
$325,000
5212159 MLS
INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY! Long term tenants occupy this 3 unit investment property located in a very high traffic area. Great visibility. The building sits adjacent to a well established drive thru and The Village of Newcomerstown Mayor's Office. Reisbeck's Food Market is one step over. The downtown area is just 2 blocks away. The property currently has an income of $2,100/mo. All 3 tenants have leases through September 2028. Tenants pay all utilities, separate meters. There is ample parking in the front of the building as well as alley bound access for employee parking and shipments. Owner pays taxes and insurance. The building has been owned by the same owners since 1989. It has been a great property. Now is the time for you to reap the benefits. These properties are rarely available. Make it your first investment property or add it to your current portfolio.

304 S College Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

$85,000
5008743 MLS
First time offered! Nice commercial property suitable for various businesses. High traffic area. Sale includes 1,629 square foot building. There is a partial basement with concrete floor, storage rooms, 2 restrooms, 2 bays, reception area, gas heat. In addition there is a 1,064 sq. ft., 3 bay garage with 1-10' door plus 2-9' doors, and gas furnace. Electric allows for air compressor operation. Ample parking in and around the station and 3 bay garage. There is also a home on the property with a long term tenant. All of the buildings have newer metal roofs, well maintained and ready for a new owner. This property has many possibilities for a new owner. It could be converted to serve many businesses. The income from the rental home is a bonus. A great place to locate with a great deal of drive by exposure. Home rents for $600/month with a long term tenant. 24 hour notice to show due to pets needing to be removed. Seller open to compressor, tire machine, and tire balancer. 24 hours notice required.

300 & 310 E Canal Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Cheryl K Hogue, cherylhoguerealtor@gmail.com With RE/MAX Crossroads Properties

Selling Office: RE/MAX Crossroads Properties.

$240,000
4463206 MLS
Come to downtown Newcomerstown to own a beautiful piece of history with heavy foot traffic. Home of Woody Hayes and CY Young. The Village of Newcomerstown is revamping this downtown area (Projects and Developments in supplements). It will have newly painted buildings, benches, new sidewalks, plants and lights. This vacant former bank branch with drive-thru and still has the vault. This would be well suited for a variety of uses. It is situated on a main retail corridor with thriving businesses. A few ideas - this would make a great restaurant, sports bar or distillery on main floor and could rent out office spaces above and below. This is a spacious Romanesque building 7000+ sq ft. Right off the 36 and 77 interchange. Home of Woody Hayes and CY Young. The local Village is prepared and willing to work with new owner to encourage new business to Main St. Building has recently been power washed. This building also features additional large amount of square footage on second floor, currently enclosed behind walls. Removing walls would significantly expand the usable 2nd story space of this building. Additional space on outside of building facing cross street of approximately 336 sqft that is part of building as well was previously used as barber shop.

150 W Main Street, Newcomerstown

Listing Courtesy of: Steven C Dailey, stevedaileyrealtor@gmail.com With Leonard and Newland Real Estate Services

Selling Office: Coldwell Banker Realty.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Coldwell Banker Realty are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.